Skip to main content
← Back to O Definitions

Open outcry

Hidden LINK_POOL:

🔹 INTERNAL LINKS

🔹 EXTERNAL LINKS

What Is Open Outcry?

Open outcry is a traditional trading method where traders communicate buy and sell orders verbally and through hand signals within a physical [trading floor] or "pit." This method is a core component of market structure, facilitating the negotiation and execution of trades for various financial instruments. Historically, open outcry was the predominant system for trading on exchanges, particularly for [futures contracts] and [options contracts]. The dynamic and often chaotic environment of an open outcry pit fostered direct, face-to-face interaction among [brokers] and traders, influencing the [price discovery] process.

History and Origin

The practice of open outcry trading dates back centuries, with its roots in 17th-century commodity markets in places like Amsterdam and London. It was a method developed out of necessity to allow traders to communicate bids and offers effectively in crowded and noisy environments. The Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME) and the New York Mercantile Exchange (NYMEX) were notable hubs for open outcry in the United States, particularly for [commodities] and [derivatives]. Over time, a sophisticated system of hand signals evolved alongside verbal shouts to ensure efficient communication and prevent misunderstandings amidst the commotion. This system remained the standard for many years until the late 20th century.

The shift away from open outcry gained significant momentum with the rise of [electronic trading] platforms. For instance, CME Group announced in February 2015 its plans to close most of its futures trading pits in Chicago and New York by July 2015, citing that open outcry futures trading had fallen to just one percent of the company's total futures volume. By Ma18, 19y 2021, CME Group permanently closed most of its open outcry trading pits, with only the Eurodollar options pit remaining open. The L15, 16, 17ondon Stock Exchange (LSE) also transitioned away from open outcry, completing its shift to electronic trading in 2007, while the London Metal Exchange (LME) discontinued its traditional ring trading in 2015. This 14widespread transition marked a significant chapter in the evolution of financial markets.

Key Takeaways

  • Open outcry is a traditional method of trading where participants use shouts and hand signals in a physical pit.
  • It facilitates direct, face-to-face interaction and historically played a crucial role in [price discovery].
  • The system involved a complex set of standardized hand signals to convey trade details efficiently.
  • While largely replaced by [electronic trading], open outcry still influences how market dynamics are understood.
  • The primary function of open outcry was to efficiently match buyers and sellers in a transparent, auction-like environment.

Interpreting the Open Outcry

In an open outcry system, the interpretation of market conditions extended beyond just prices and quantities. Traders in the pit could gain insights by observing the facial expressions, body language, and overall demeanor of other participants. This human element was believed to provide an additional layer of information, allowing traders to gauge the sentiment, urgency, or even potential motives of buyers and sellers. The volume and intensity of shouting, combined with the quick, decisive hand signals, provided a real-time pulse of market [liquidity] and volatility. While not a numerical measure, the perceived "energy" of the pit offered a qualitative assessment of market depth and immediate supply and demand dynamics, influencing how traders positioned themselves and executed [order matching].

Hypothetical Example

Imagine a bustling trading pit for corn [futures contracts] in the early 2000s. Trader A, wanting to buy 500 contracts, might shout, "Buying 500 at 3.50!" while simultaneously holding up five fingers to indicate 500 units and making a hand signal to denote a buy order. Trader B, looking to sell 500 contracts at that price, would acknowledge with a corresponding hand signal and a verbal affirmation, "Sold 500 at 3.50!" The "pit reporter" or exchange clerk would then record this trade. The swift, public exchange of information, both verbal and non-verbal, ensured that all participants in the pit were aware of the prevailing bids and offers, contributing to the immediate [price discovery] for corn futures. This rapid, in-person negotiation allowed for quick adjustments to prices and quantities based on the immediate reaction of other traders.

Practical Applications

While significantly diminished, understanding open outcry remains relevant for appreciating the historical evolution of [financial markets] and the principles of [market efficiency]. The competitive environment of the trading pits fostered transparency and efficient price discovery, principles that remain cornerstones of modern [electronic trading] systems. Although the physical pits have largely disappeared, the concepts of a visible [bid-ask spread] and immediate [order matching] developed in open outcry are fundamental to how automated systems function today.

Moreover, certain niche markets or specific [options contracts] may still have limited forms of floor trading or hybrid systems. For example, the Eurodollar options pit at CME Group continues to operate using open outcry. The S13ecurities and Exchange Commission (SEC), while largely focused on electronic markets, has historically overseen the transition and adaptation of trading practices to ensure fair and orderly markets. The S12EC's role extends to monitoring trading activities to detect and address manipulative practices, which were also a concern in the open outcry environment.

L10, 11imitations and Criticisms

Despite its historical significance, open outcry trading had several limitations that ultimately led to its decline. One major drawback was its inherent reliance on physical presence, which limited global accessibility and scalability. Only individuals physically present on the [trading floor] could participate, creating barriers to entry for remote traders. The s9heer noise and chaotic nature of the pits, while fostering transparency, could also lead to miscommunication or misinterpretation of orders, increasing the potential for [execution risk].

Another significant criticism revolved around the potential for [market manipulation] and information asymmetry. While proponents argued for the transparency of "the pit," some argued that experienced floor traders could gain an edge through subtle non-verbal cues or by strategically positioning themselves, creating temporary information advantages that are less prevalent in automated systems. The human element, while offering certain benefits, also introduced the potential for human error and slower [trade execution] speeds compared to the millisecond transactions of modern [algorithmic trading]. The transition to [electronic trading] was driven by the desire for greater speed, efficiency, and cost-effectiveness, as well as enhanced accessibility and auditability.

O7, 8pen Outcry vs. Electronic Trading

Open outcry and [electronic trading] represent two fundamentally different approaches to executing financial transactions. The primary distinction lies in the method of communication and interaction. Open outcry involves physical, face-to-face communication through shouts and hand signals within a designated trading pit. In contrast, electronic trading relies on computerized systems where orders are entered digitally and matched automatically.

FeatureOpen OutcryElectronic Trading
Execution SpeedSlower, dependent on human interactionMilliseconds, automated and instantaneous
AccessibilityLimited to those physically on the trading floorGlobal, accessible remotely via computers
TransparencyVisual and auditory cues in the pitReal-time data feeds, historical records, audit trails
CostHigher overhead (physical floor, personnel)Lower [transaction costs] for exchanges and traders
Information FlowRelies on verbal, visual, and non-verbal cuesPurely digital data, quantitative analysis
AnonymityLess anonymous (face-to-face)High degree of anonymity

The shift from open outcry to electronic trading has transformed market dynamics, emphasizing speed, efficiency, and global access. While6 electronic systems offer benefits such as advanced analytics and broader market participation, some argue that the human element and nuanced interactions of open outcry trading are lost.

F5AQs

What types of products were typically traded via open outcry?

Historically, a wide range of financial products were traded via open outcry, most notably [futures contracts] and [options contracts] on exchanges like the CME and NYMEX. This included [commodities] such as agricultural products, metals, and energy, as well as financial [derivatives] like interest rate futures and [equity indexes].

Why did exchanges move away from open outcry?

Exchanges transitioned away from open outcry primarily due to the advent and efficiency of [electronic trading] systems. Electronic platforms offer significantly faster [trade execution], lower [transaction costs], greater accessibility for global participants, and improved [market transparency] through real-time data and audit trails.

4Are there any markets that still use open outcry?

As of mid-2020s, very few markets still extensively use open outcry. The CME Group, for example, permanently closed most of its open outcry pits in 2021, though its Eurodollar [options contracts] pit remains an exception, operating a hybrid system. The L3ondon Metal Exchange (LME) also maintained a form of "ring trading" for a period, though it too has largely transitioned.

How did traders communicate in the pits?

Traders communicated in the pits through a combination of loud verbal shouts, known as "crying," and a complex system of standardized [hand signals]. These signals conveyed crucial information such as whether an order was a buy or sell, the quantity of contracts, and the desired price. The hand signals allowed for clear communication amidst the noisy environment of the [trading floor].1, 2