Open positions: Meaning, Criticisms & Real-World Uses

_LINK_POOL:

What Is Open Positions?

In finance, an open position refers to a trade that has been executed but not yet closed or offset. This means an investor has bought a security but not yet sold it, or has sold a security (typically short) but not yet bought it back. Open positions represent an active investment that is subject to market fluctuations and carries ongoing market risk. They are a fundamental concept within financial markets and the broader field of investment management.

An open position exists until an offsetting transaction is made. For example, if an investor buys 100 shares of Company X, that is an open long position. If they later sell those 100 shares, the position is closed. Conversely, if an investor sells 50 shares of Company Y short, that is an open short position, which is closed when they buy back 50 shares of Company Y.

History and Origin

The concept of an open position is as old as organized trading itself. Early forms of securities trading involved individuals agreeing to buy or sell assets, creating obligations that remained "open" until fulfilled. The formalization of these agreements began with the establishment of stock exchanges. One of the earliest examples in the United States is the Buttonwood Agreement, signed on May 17, 1792, by 24 stockbrokers and merchants in New York City. This agreement laid the groundwork for what would become the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE), establishing rules for trading and setting commission fees¹⁶. By creating a more orderly system for transactions, the agreement implicitly defined open positions as the commitments held by brokers and their clients. Before this, trading was often unregulated, leading to frequent disputes over unsettled trades¹⁵. The agreement aimed to re-establish trust in the marketplace and safeguard investors' interests, centralizing the process of taking and closing positions in various securities ¹⁴.

Key Takeaways

An open position is a financial trade that has been initiated but not yet closed by an offsetting transaction.
It represents a current exposure to market movements, carrying both potential profit and risk.
Open positions can be either "long" (owning an asset) or "short" (owing an asset, typically from borrowing and selling).
The management of open positions is central to a trader's or investor's risk management strategy.
Brokers and financial institutions closely monitor open positions, especially in leveraged accounts, to manage their own exposure and ensure regulatory compliance.

Interpreting the Open Positions

Interpreting open positions primarily involves understanding the associated risk and potential reward. For a long open position, the investor benefits if the price of the asset increases. For a short open position, the investor benefits if the price decreases. The size of an open position, combined with the volatility of the underlying asset, directly impacts the potential profit or loss.

The time horizon for which a position remains open is also a crucial factor. Short-term open positions are typically associated with day trading or swing trading strategies, where market movements are closely monitored. Long-term open positions, often seen in buy-and-hold investing, are less sensitive to daily price fluctuations. Investors also consider the total value of their open positions relative to their overall portfolio to assess their aggregate market exposure. Furthermore, the type of financial instrument held in an open position, such as stocks, bonds, or derivatives, dictates the specific risks and characteristics associated with it.

Hypothetical Example

Consider an investor, Sarah, who believes that Company ABC's stock price will rise. On Monday, she decides to open a long position by purchasing 100 shares of Company ABC at $50 per share. Her total investment for this open position is $5,000 (100 shares * $50/share).

If, by Friday, the price of Company ABC's shares has risen to $55 per share, Sarah's open position has a
current market value of $5,500 (100 shares * $55/share). At this point, she has an unrealized gain of $500. If she were to sell her shares, she would close the position and realize this profit.

Conversely, if the price of Company ABC's shares falls to $48 per share by Friday, her open position now has a market value of $4,800. She has an unrealized loss of $200. If she sells at this price, she closes the position and realizes the loss. Until she executes an offsetting trade (selling the shares), her position remains open and its value fluctuates with the market price.

Practical Applications

Open positions are central to virtually all aspects of financial trading and investing. In the stock market, investors hold open positions in common and preferred stocks, aiming for capital appreciation or dividend income¹², ¹³. Professional traders actively manage numerous open positions across various asset classes, including commodities, currencies, and fixed-income securities.

For brokerages and clearing firms, tracking open positions is a critical operational and regulatory requirement. They must report customer balances, including open margin positions, to regulatory bodies such as FINRA (Financial Industry Regulatory Authority)¹⁰, ¹¹. FINRA Rule 4521, for example, requires member firms that carry customer margin accounts to submit total debit balances and free credit balances to FINRA on a monthly basis⁸, ⁹. This rule ensures transparency and helps monitor the overall financial health of brokerage firms and their customers.

A notable instance of the impact of unmanaged open positions was the collapse of Archegos Capital Management in March 2021. Archegos, a family office, had amassed highly leveraged, concentrated open positions in certain stocks through total return swaps. When the market moved against these positions, Archegos failed to meet its collateral demands (margin calls) from its prime broker-dealers, leading to a forced liquidation of billions of dollars in stocks and significant losses for several major investment banks⁶, ⁷. This event underscored the importance of robust risk management and proper oversight of open positions, especially those with high leverage.

Limitations and Criticisms

While essential to trading, open positions come with inherent limitations and criticisms. The primary concern is exposure to market risk; until a position is closed, unrealized gains can turn into losses, and unrealized losses can deepen. This uncertainty highlights the importance of timely decision-making and exit strategies.

Another criticism revolves around the use of leverage to magnify open positions. While leverage can amplify returns, it also amplifies losses, potentially leading to significant financial distress or even bankruptcy if not managed properly⁴, ⁵. The Archegos Capital Management collapse serves as a stark reminder of the dangers associated with highly leveraged open positions and the systemic risks they can pose to financial institutions.

Furthermore, maintaining open positions can tie up capital, impacting an investor's overall liquidity. Depending on the nature of the position and the market, it might be difficult to close a large open position quickly without impacting the market price, especially for less liquid securities. This can lead to increased costs or less favorable execution prices when attempting to close a position.

Open Positions vs. Closed Positions

The key distinction between open positions and closed positions lies in their status regarding market exposure and realized gains or losses.

Feature	Open Positions	Closed Positions
Market Exposure	Active exposure to market price fluctuations	No ongoing market exposure
Profit/Loss	Unrealized gains or losses	Realized gains or losses
Capital Status	Capital is tied up in the investment	Capital is freed up from the investment
Future Action	Requires an offsetting trade to close	No further action required for the trade
Risk	Ongoing market risk and potential for further loss	No further risk from the specific trade

An open position represents a present commitment to the market, with the outcome still undetermined. Conversely, a closed position signifies the completion of a trade cycle, where the profit or loss has been locked in and reflected on the investor's profit and loss statement and potentially their balance sheet.

FAQs

What does "open long position" mean?

An "open long position" means you have bought a security and currently own it, expecting its price to rise. You will make a profit if the price increases, and a loss if it decreases, until you sell the security to close the position.

What is the difference between an open position and a pending order?

An open position is an executed trade that you currently hold. A pending order, on the other hand, is an instruction to your broker-dealer to execute a trade at a future price or time. Until the conditions of the pending order are met and the trade is executed, it does not become an open position.

How does an open position affect my margin account?

In a margin account, open positions purchased with borrowed funds increase your leverage and your margin debt. The value of these open positions directly impacts your account's equity and maintenance margin requirements. If the value of your open positions falls too much, you may receive a margin call, requiring you to deposit additional funds or liquidate positions.

When does an open position become a closed position?

An open position becomes a closed position when an offsetting transaction is executed. For a long position (you bought first), it closes when you sell the same amount of the security. For a short position (you sold first), it closes when you buy back the same amount of the security. The settlement date is the date by which the trade officially clears and funds/securities are exchanged.

Why do financial regulators care about open positions?

Financial regulators, such as the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and FINRA, monitor open positions to ensure market stability, protect investors, and prevent excessive leverage and systemic risk¹, ², ³. They often require broker-dealers to report aggregated open position data to assess market exposure and prevent practices that could destabilize the financial system.