Option adjusted spread

Hidden table:

What Is Option Adjusted Spread?

The Option Adjusted Spread (OAS) is a sophisticated metric in fixed-income analysis that quantifies the yield premium required by investors for holding a fixed-income security with embedded options, relative to a benchmark risk-free rate. It falls under the broader financial category of [bond valuation]. Unlike simpler spread measures, OAS accounts for how these [embedded options], such as call or put provisions, can influence a bond's future [cash flows] and its overall value. The calculation of the option adjusted spread involves complex [financial models] that simulate various future [interest rates] scenarios to determine the bond's expected price and yield, thereby isolating the compensation for the option risk.

History and Origin

The concept of option-adjusted spread gained prominence with the increasing complexity of fixed-income instruments, particularly [mortgage-backed securities] (MBS) which inherently contain prepayment options. As the bond market evolved to include more securities with dynamic cash flow characteristics, traditional yield measures proved insufficient to accurately assess their relative value. The need for a more comprehensive valuation framework that could account for the stochastic nature of interest rates and the behavioral aspects of embedded options led to the development and adoption of OAS. This was particularly critical during periods of high interest rate volatility, and its application became widespread in the analysis of MBS and [callable bonds]. For instance, during the 2008 financial crisis, the complex nature of MBS and their associated prepayment risks became a focal point for financial institutions and regulators, highlighting the importance of robust valuation tools like OAS. The Federal Reserve's involvement in the MBS market also underscored the need for advanced models to project principal payments, which are significantly influenced by embedded prepayment options⁵⁹, ⁶⁰, ⁶¹.

Key Takeaways

• The Option Adjusted Spread (OAS) measures the yield premium of a bond with embedded options over a risk-free rate, accounting for the value of those options.
• It is a dynamic measure that uses probabilistic [financial models] to simulate various interest rate paths and their impact on a bond's cash flows.
• OAS allows for a more accurate comparison of bonds with different embedded options, providing a clearer picture of their relative value and risk-return trade-offs⁵⁷, ⁵⁸.
• A positive OAS generally indicates that a bond offers a yield premium for the additional risks associated with its embedded options⁵⁵, ⁵⁶.
• The calculation of OAS is model-dependent and sensitive to assumptions about interest rate volatility and prepayment behavior⁵³, ⁵⁴.

Formula and Calculation

The option adjusted spread is not a simple direct calculation but rather an output derived through iterative valuation models that consider various interest rate paths. Conceptually, the OAS is the spread that, when added to each point on the benchmark spot [yield curve], makes the theoretical price of a bond (derived from a complex model that accounts for embedded options) equal to its observed market price.

While the exact calculation involves complex numerical methods like Monte Carlo simulations or binomial interest rate trees, the underlying relationship can be expressed as:

Where:

• (\text{Market Price}) = The observed market price of the bond.
• (\text{Expected Cash Flow}_t) = The projected [cash flows] at time (t), adjusted for the exercise of any [embedded options] (e.g., prepayments for MBS or calls for [callable bonds]).
• (\text{Risk-Free Rate}_t) = The spot rate from the benchmark Treasury [yield curve] at time (t). These rates are often obtained from sources like the Federal Reserve's H.15 statistical release, which provides selected interest rates for U.S. government securities⁵⁰, ⁵¹, ⁵².
• (\text{OAS}) = The Option Adjusted Spread, which is the value being solved for.
• (N) = The number of cash flow periods.

For a bond with a callable feature, the issuer benefits from the option, leading to a lower OAS compared to the Z-spread. Conversely, for [putable bonds], where the investor benefits from the option, the OAS will be higher than the Z-spread⁴⁸, ⁴⁹.

Interpreting the Option Adjusted Spread

The interpretation of the option adjusted spread provides valuable insights into the pricing and relative attractiveness of bonds with embedded options. A higher OAS suggests that a bond offers a greater yield premium above the risk-free rate to compensate investors for the embedded optionality and other risks like [credit risk] and [liquidity risk]. Investors can use OAS to compare securities that might otherwise appear similar based on nominal yields but have different embedded features⁴⁶, ⁴⁷.

For example, two bonds with identical credit ratings and maturities might have different nominal yields. If one bond has a call option, its OAS will typically be lower than a comparable option-free bond because the issuer's call option reduces the bond's value to the investor⁴³, ⁴⁴, ⁴⁵. Conversely, a putable bond, where the investor has the right to sell the bond back to the issuer, would generally have a higher OAS, reflecting the value of this embedded investor option⁴¹, ⁴². The OAS helps normalize these differences, allowing investors to assess the "true" compensation for non-option related risks.

Hypothetical Example

Consider two hypothetical corporate bonds, Bond A and Bond B, each with a par value of $1,000 and a five-year maturity. Assume the current risk-free yield curve is flat at 3%.

Bond A is an option-free bond with a coupon rate of 4%. Through a standard bond valuation model, its market price is determined to be $1,044.52.

Bond B is a callable bond with a coupon rate of 4.5%. Due to its call feature, its future cash flows are uncertain. Using a sophisticated OAS model that simulates various interest rate scenarios and accounts for the issuer's propensity to call the bond, the model determines that the bond's theoretical price, when discounted at the risk-free rate plus a spread of 50 basis points (0.50%), equals its market price of $1,021.75.

In this scenario:

• For Bond A (option-free), its spread over the risk-free rate would be its yield to maturity minus the risk-free rate, adjusted for any [credit risk].
• For Bond B (callable), the option adjusted spread is 50 basis points. This means that, after accounting for the value of the embedded call option, the bond provides an additional 0.50% yield above the risk-free rate to compensate for its remaining risks. If Bond B had a Z-spread (which doesn't adjust for the option) of, say, 70 basis points, the 20 basis points difference would represent the cost of the call option to the investor (70 bps Z-spread – 50 bps OAS = 20 bps option cost).
  ⁴⁰
  This example highlights how OAS isolates the spread attributable to factors other than the embedded option, offering a more apples-to-apples comparison of the bonds' relative value.

Practical Applications

Option adjusted spread is a crucial analytical tool in several areas of finance:

• Portfolio Management: Fund managers utilize OAS to compare the relative attractiveness of various [fixed-income security] with [embedded options], such as [mortgage-backed securities] (MBS), [callable bonds], and [derivatives]. It enables them to identify potentially undervalued or overvalued securities by providing a more accurate measure of expected return after accounting for optionality. ³⁷, ³⁸, ³⁹This helps in optimizing portfolio construction and managing interest rate exposure.
• Risk Management: OAS helps in assessing the complex risks associated with option-embedded bonds. By understanding the portion of a bond's [yield] that compensates for optionality, financial institutions can better gauge their exposure to interest rate volatility and prepayment risk. ³⁶The Federal Reserve, for instance, employs MBS prepayment models to project principal payments, recognizing that these payments are heavily influenced by embedded prepayment options.
  ³⁵* Valuation and Pricing: OAS is widely used by bond traders and analysts for accurate [bond valuation]. It helps in determining a fair market price for complex securities by accounting for various possible interest rate paths and the probability of option exercise. ³⁴Historical OAS data for indices like the ICE BofA AA US Corporate Index can be tracked to understand trends in corporate bond spreads.
  ³², ³³* Arbitrage Opportunities: Sophisticated investors may look for discrepancies between a bond's calculated OAS and its peers to identify potential arbitrage opportunities. If a bond's OAS is significantly higher than similar securities, it might suggest the bond is undervalued relative to its risk profile.
  ³¹

Limitations and Criticisms

Despite its widespread use and theoretical advantages, the option adjusted spread has several limitations and criticisms:

• Model Dependence: The calculation of OAS relies heavily on complex [financial models] that incorporate assumptions about future interest rate movements, volatility, and prepayment behavior. ²⁹, ³⁰The accuracy of the OAS is therefore highly dependent on the quality and assumptions of these models. Different models or even slight changes in input assumptions can lead to significantly different OAS values, making comparisons across different analytical platforms challenging.
  ²⁷, ²⁸* Assumption Sensitivity: OAS models often rely on historical data for estimating parameters like prepayment rates. However, economic conditions and borrower behavior can change, rendering historical assumptions less relevant for future predictions. For example, prepayment models for [mortgage-backed securities] are highly sensitive to prevailing [interest rates] and other factors, but these models may not fully capture behavioral aspects or economic shifts.
  ²⁶* Complexity and Interpretation: The intricate nature of OAS calculations can make it difficult for non-specialists to fully understand and interpret the results. ²⁴, ²⁵While OAS aims to provide an option-free spread, its interpretation can sometimes be misleading if the underlying complexities are not appreciated.
  ²², ²³* Ignored Risks: While OAS accounts for interest rate and option risk, it may not fully capture other important risks such as [credit risk] or [liquidity risk]. Some models might subsume these risks into the OAS rather than explicitly modeling them, potentially leading to an incomplete picture of total risk. ²¹For instance, a paper published by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York discusses how the accuracy of OAS prices heavily depends on the efficacy of prepayment projections, and that the analysis is not an exact process due to subjective assumptions.
  ²⁰* Averaged Nature: OAS is an averaged number, averaged across various simulated interest rate paths and through time. This averaging might obscure important details about the distribution of potential outcomes or the sensitivity of a security to specific market events.
  ¹⁹

Option Adjusted Spread vs. Z-Spread

The Option Adjusted Spread (OAS) and the Z-spread (Zero-Volatility Spread) are both measures used in fixed-income analysis to assess the yield premium of a bond. However, they differ fundamentally in how they treat [embedded options].

The primary point of confusion often arises because the Z-spread captures all sources of spread, including that due to embedded optionality, whereas the OAS attempts to remove the influence of the option, providing a cleaner measure of the bond's underlying credit and [liquidity risk].
⁶, ⁷, ⁸

FAQs

Why is Option Adjusted Spread used?

The Option Adjusted Spread (OAS) is used to provide a more accurate and comparable measure of a bond's [yield] when that bond has [embedded options] that affect its future [cash flows]. Traditional yield measures don't account for these options, making it difficult to assess the true value and risk of complex securities like [mortgage-backed securities] or [callable bonds].

How does OAS account for interest rate volatility?

OAS accounts for [interest rates] volatility by using dynamic [financial models] that simulate hundreds or thousands of potential future interest rate paths. Along each path, the model determines if and when the embedded option would be exercised (e.g., a mortgage prepayment or bond call). By averaging the present values of the cash flows across all these simulated paths, the OAS calculation effectively incorporates the impact of interest rate uncertainty on the bond's value.
⁵

What is a "good" Option Adjusted Spread?

There isn't a universally "good" OAS value, as it depends on the specific bond, its [credit risk], [liquidity risk], and market conditions. Generally, for similar bonds with comparable risks, a higher OAS indicates that the bond is offering more compensation (a higher yield premium) to the investor. This could suggest that the bond is undervalued relative to its peers. ³, ⁴However, it's crucial to compare OAS values only among truly comparable securities and to consider the assumptions underlying the calculation.

Does OAS consider prepayment risk for MBS?

Yes, OAS explicitly considers [prepayment risk] for [mortgage-backed securities] (MBS). For MBS, the "option" in option adjusted spread primarily refers to the homeowner's right to prepay their mortgage. The OAS model incorporates prepayment models that estimate how changes in [interest rates] and other factors might influence borrowers to refinance or sell their homes, thereby altering the MBS's expected cash flows.
²

Is Option Adjusted Spread the same as Z-spread?

No, Option Adjusted Spread (OAS) is not the same as Z-spread. While both are bond spreads, the Z-spread is a constant spread added to the entire benchmark [yield curve] to match a bond's market price, without considering [embedded options]. OAS, on the other hand, adjusts the Z-spread to account for the value of these options. This means OAS provides a measure of spread that is theoretically "option-free," representing compensation for non-option related risks.¹