Skip to main content
← Back to O Definitions

Over the counter markets

What Are Over the Counter Markets?

Over the counter (OTC) markets constitute a decentralized financial market where participants trade directly with one another, rather than through a centralized exchange. This form of trading falls under the broader category of financial markets. Unlike traditional stock exchanges with physical locations or central order books, OTC transactions occur via a network of broker-dealers who negotiate trades directly by phone, email, or proprietary electronic systems. The term "over the counter" refers to the historical practice of trading shares literally over the counter of a bank or brokerage.

OTC markets facilitate the trading of various financial instruments, including equity securities (especially those of smaller, less-established companies), corporate bonds, government securities, and derivatives. These markets are characterized by their flexibility and the direct negotiation of prices, often involving specialized market makers who stand ready to buy and sell particular securities.

History and Origin

The concept of over the counter trading predates formal stock exchanges. In the early days of finance, transactions occurred directly between parties. As markets matured, the need for organized trading venues led to the establishment of exchanges. However, for companies that were too small, new, or did not meet the listing requirements of formal exchanges, the OTC method persisted.

A significant development in the U.S. OTC market began in 1904 with the National Quotation Bureau (NQB), which published an inter-dealer quotation service on pink-colored paper, leading to the informal name "Pink Sheets." This system served as a primary mechanism for quoting prices of unlisted securities for decades. In 1990, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) requested the National Association of Securities Dealers (NASD), the predecessor to the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), to create and manage the Over The Counter Bulletin Board (OTCBB) to provide greater transparency and access to capital for smaller companies.15 The OTCBB aimed to offer a more structured environment for OTC equities by requiring companies to file reports with the SEC to be quoted.14 Over time, other electronic quotation systems evolved, such as those operated by OTC Markets Group, which now provides multiple tiers of OTC trading.

Key Takeaways

  • Over the counter (OTC) markets involve direct, decentralized trading between participants, bypassing traditional stock exchanges.
  • OTC markets facilitate trade in a wide range of financial instruments, from stocks and bonds to complex derivatives.
  • These markets offer flexibility and can provide capital formation avenues for smaller companies not listed on major exchanges.
  • Trading in OTC markets often involves lower liquidity and greater price volatility compared to exchange-traded securities.
  • Regulatory oversight exists, but disclosure requirements for many OTC securities can be less stringent than for exchange-listed ones, posing higher risks for investors.

Formula and Calculation

Over the counter markets themselves do not have a specific "formula" for calculation. Instead, the pricing of securities traded within OTC markets is determined through direct negotiation between buyers and sellers, often facilitated by market makers. The price an investor receives for an OTC security will depend on various factors including the company's financial health, supply and demand dynamics, and the competitive quotes offered by different broker-dealers. The "bid-ask spread" represents the difference between the highest price a buyer is willing to pay (bid) and the lowest price a seller is willing to accept (ask). This spread can be wider for less liquid OTC securities.

Interpreting Over the Counter Markets

Interpreting activities within over the counter markets requires understanding their unique characteristics, particularly concerning price discovery and transparency. Unlike exchange-traded securities where prices are centrally displayed and reflect consolidated demand and supply, OTC prices are negotiated. This means that the "price" of an OTC security can vary between different broker-dealers at any given moment. Investors must rely on the diligence of their broker-dealer to ensure "best execution" – obtaining the most favorable terms reasonably available for their order.

13The scale of OTC markets, particularly for derivatives, is substantial. For instance, the notional value of outstanding over-the-counter derivatives globally reached hundreds of trillions of dollars as of mid-2024, as tracked by the Bank for International Settlements (BIS). W12hile this notional value is large, the actual gross market value of these contracts is significantly smaller, as many positions are offsetting and used for risk management.

Hypothetical Example

Imagine "GreenTech Innovations Inc." is a startup developing new sustainable energy technology. It's a small company and doesn't yet meet the strict revenue or shareholder equity requirements to list its shares on a major stock exchange like the New York Stock Exchange or Nasdaq. To raise capital, GreenTech Innovations decides to have its shares traded on an over the counter market.

An investor, Sarah, is very interested in GreenTech's technology and wants to buy shares. Her broker-dealer contacts several market makers who are willing to quote prices for GreenTech's stock. Broker-Dealer A might offer to sell GreenTech shares at $0.52 and buy at $0.48. Broker-Dealer B might offer to sell at $0.51 and buy at $0.47. Sarah's broker-dealer, seeking the best execution, would execute her buy order with Broker-Dealer B at $0.51, since it's the lowest available selling price. This direct negotiation between broker-dealers, rather than trading on a central order book, is characteristic of an over the counter transaction.

Practical Applications

Over the counter markets serve several practical applications across the financial landscape:

  • Emerging Companies: They provide a vital avenue for smaller, developing companies to raise capital and gain public visibility without the stringent requirements and costs associated with major exchange listings.
  • Fixed Income Trading: A vast majority of fixed income securities, including government bonds and corporate bonds, are traded over the counter. This allows for customized transactions between large institutional investors.
  • Derivatives Trading: Complex financial instruments like interest rate swaps, credit default swaps, and customized options are primarily traded in the OTC derivatives market, enabling institutions to tailor contracts to specific hedging or speculative needs. The notional value of outstanding OTC derivatives continued an upward trend, growing by 9% in the first half of 2024.
    *11 Foreign Exchange (FX): The global foreign exchange market is the largest OTC market, where currency trades occur directly between banks and other financial institutions worldwide.
  • Private Placements: These markets facilitate private placements, where securities are sold directly to a small number of investors without a public offering.

Limitations and Criticisms

Despite their utility, over the counter markets have notable limitations and criticisms, primarily stemming from their decentralized nature and often lower disclosure requirements.

  • Limited Transparency: Compared to exchanges, OTC markets can offer less transparency regarding pricing and trading volumes. This can make it difficult for investors to ascertain the true market value of a security, leading to potentially less favorable execution prices.
  • Higher Risk of Fraud: The lack of comprehensive public information for many OTC-traded companies, particularly microcap stocks, makes them more susceptible to fraudulent schemes like "pump-and-dump" operations. T9, 10he SEC actively monitors and enforces against such manipulations due to the increased vulnerability of less sophisticated retail investors in these markets.
    *8 Lower Liquidity: Many OTC securities, especially those of smaller companies, experience significantly lower liquidity than exchange-listed stocks. This means it can be challenging to buy or sell these securities quickly without substantially impacting their price, potentially leading to greater losses.
    *6, 7 Price Volatility: Due to lower liquidity and less available information, OTC stocks can exhibit higher price volatility. Large price swings can occur from relatively small trades or promotional activities.
    *4, 5 Regulatory Scrutiny: While FINRA and the SEC regulate broker-dealer activities in OTC markets, the disclosure requirements for some OTC-traded companies are less stringent than for those listed on national exchanges. F3or example, an amendment to SEC Rule 15c2-11 in 2021 aimed to increase minimum disclosure requirements for OTC securities, prohibiting broker-dealers from quoting non-compliant securities to enhance transparency.

1, 2## Over the Counter Markets vs. Stock Exchanges

The fundamental difference between over the counter markets and stock exchanges lies in their structure and the method of transaction.

FeatureOver the Counter (OTC) MarketsStock Exchanges
StructureDecentralized network of broker-dealers.Centralized trading venue with a single order book.
Trading MethodDirect negotiation between parties, often through market makers.Buyers and sellers place orders that are matched by the exchange's system.
TransparencyGenerally lower, as prices are negotiated and not always publicly consolidated in real-time.High, with real-time consolidated prices and volumes displayed to all participants.
RegulationRegulated by bodies like the SEC and FINRA, but disclosure requirements for issuers can be less stringent for some tiers.Highly regulated with stringent listing requirements and continuous disclosure obligations for listed companies.
LiquidityCan be lower, especially for smaller companies or less common financial instruments.Generally higher due to centralized trading and broader participation.
ExamplesOTCQX, OTCQB, OTC Pink, bond markets, foreign exchange market.New York Stock Exchange (NYSE), Nasdaq Stock Market.

Confusion often arises because both facilitate the buying and selling of securities. However, the "how" of the trade—whether it's direct and negotiated (OTC) or centralized and matched (exchange)—is the key distinguishing factor.

FAQs

What is the primary difference between an OTC market and a stock exchange?

The main difference is decentralization. An OTC market is a network where trades occur directly between participants, while a stock exchange is a centralized venue with a single trading system where all orders are matched.

What kinds of securities are typically traded on OTC markets?

OTC markets are used for a wide range of securities, including stocks of smaller companies that don't meet exchange listing requirements, corporate bonds, government securities, and various types of derivatives. The vast foreign exchange market is also an OTC market.

Are OTC markets regulated?

Yes, OTC markets are regulated, primarily by authorities like the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) in the United States. However, the level of disclosure required for companies whose securities trade on OTC markets can vary and may be less stringent than for exchange-listed companies.

Why would a company choose to have its stock traded on an OTC market instead of an exchange?

Smaller or newer companies might choose OTC markets because they have less stringent listing requirements and lower associated costs compared to major exchanges. This allows them to raise capital and gain investor exposure earlier in their development.

What are the risks of investing in securities traded on OTC markets?

Investing in OTC securities often carries higher risks due to potential lower liquidity, greater price volatility, and less available public information about the issuing companies. These factors can make them more susceptible to manipulation and can result in significant losses for investors.