Skip to main content
← Back to P Definitions

Pharmacy benefit manager

What Is a Pharmacy Benefit Manager?

A pharmacy benefit manager (PBM) is a third-party administrator that manages prescription drug benefits on behalf of health insurers, employers, unions, and government programs. Operating within the broader category of Healthcare Finance, PBMs act as intermediaries in the complex supply chain for prescription drugs, aiming to control healthcare costs and improve patient outcomes. Their primary functions include developing drug lists, known as formularies, negotiating prices and rebates with pharmaceutical manufacturers, and processing prescription claims.

History and Origin

The concept of pharmacy benefit managers emerged in the United States in the 1960s, as insurance companies began to integrate prescription drug coverage into health benefit plans.17 Initially, PBMs primarily focused on facilitating payments for covered medications and administering drug claims.15, 16 Their role expanded significantly in the 1970s with the advent of electronic claims adjudication, allowing for real-time processing of prescriptions at the pharmacy counter.14

Over time, PBMs evolved from mere claims processors to entities deeply involved in managing the cost and utilization of medications for their clients.13 This evolution included the development of formularies and the negotiation of discounts with drug manufacturers, leveraging the collective purchasing power of their client base.12 The industry continued to grow, with PBMs becoming central to the administration of drug benefits for millions of Americans.11

Key Takeaways

  • Pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) are third-party entities that administer prescription drug benefits for health plans.
  • PBMs negotiate drug prices and rebates with manufacturers and establish formularies, which are lists of covered drugs.
  • They manage the pharmacy network, process claims, and implement cost-control measures like prior authorizations and step therapy.
  • PBMs aim to reduce overall drug spending for their clients and members, though their practices have faced scrutiny.
  • They play a crucial role in determining patient access to medications and out-of-pocket costs.

Interpreting the Pharmacy Benefit Manager

A pharmacy benefit manager's role is interpreted through its impact on the accessibility and affordability of prescription medications for beneficiaries of a benefit plan. PBMs influence which drugs are covered, the patient's copayment or deductible, and even where medications can be filled. By negotiating lower prices and securing rebates from manufacturers, PBMs theoretically reduce the net cost of drugs for health plans and, by extension, their members.10 The effectiveness of a PBM is often measured by its ability to achieve significant savings through these negotiations and by managing drug utilization to promote cost-effectiveness without compromising patient care.

Hypothetical Example

Consider "HealthShield Inc.," a health insurance company that contracts with "MediRx PBM" to manage its prescription drug benefits. HealthShield's members include individuals and employees from various companies, all covered under its plans.

  1. Formulary Management: MediRx PBM develops a tiered formulary for HealthShield. This formulary categorizes drugs into tiers (e.g., generic, preferred brand, non-preferred brand, specialty), each with a different copayment level for the patient. MediRx negotiates with pharmaceutical manufacturers to include their drugs on specific tiers, often in exchange for rebates.
  2. Claim Processing: When a HealthShield member fills a prescription at a participating pharmacy, the pharmacy sends the claim to MediRx PBM for processing. MediRx verifies the member's eligibility, applies the correct benefit design (e.g., copayment, deductible, or co-insurance), and determines the amount HealthShield will reimburse the pharmacy and the amount the member owes.
  3. Cost Savings: If a new high-cost medication enters the market, MediRx PBM might negotiate a favorable price or rebate with its manufacturer. Alternatively, MediRx might implement utilization management tools, such as requiring prior authorization or step therapy, to ensure the drug is medically necessary and that less costly, equally effective alternatives have been tried first, thus managing drug pricing. These actions aim to keep overall prescription costs down for HealthShield and its members.

Practical Applications

Pharmacy benefit managers are integral to the modern healthcare system, impacting several areas:

  • Insurance and Employer-Sponsored Plans: PBMs administer prescription drug components for commercial health insurance plans, self-insured employers, and union employee benefits programs. They are responsible for a range of services from designing benefit plans to operating mail-order pharmacies.9
  • Medicare Part D: PBMs play a significant role in Medicare Part D plans, managing drug benefits for millions of seniors and individuals with disabilities. Their negotiations influence the drugs available and their costs within these federal programs.
  • Government Oversight: PBM practices have drawn increasing attention from state and federal regulators. All 50 U.S. states have enacted legislation to regulate PBMs in some capacity, addressing issues such as transparency, spread pricing, and pharmacy reimbursement.8 These regulations aim to enhance oversight and ensure fair practices within the industry. For instance, the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) has reviewed state-level regulations concerning PBM operations.7
  • Managed Care Organizations: PBMs are a core component of managed care models, providing expertise in pharmaceutical management, formulary development, and clinical programs aimed at improving medication adherence and health outcomes.6

Limitations and Criticisms

Despite their stated goal of reducing prescription drug costs, pharmacy benefit managers face significant criticism regarding their practices and transparency. A primary concern is "spread pricing," where a PBM charges a health plan more for a drug than it reimburses the pharmacy, keeping the difference as profit.5 This lack of transparency about how PBMs derive revenue has led to calls for greater oversight.

Another criticism centers on manufacturer rebates. PBMs negotiate rebates from drug manufacturers in exchange for preferred formulary placement. Critics argue that PBMs may have an incentive to favor high-list-price drugs that offer larger rebates, rather than lower-cost alternatives, and may not pass the full savings onto health plans or patients.4 This can potentially increase patient out-of-pocket costs, especially for those with high-deductible health plans.3

Vertical integration, where large PBMs are owned by or affiliated with major health insurers and sometimes their own mail-order or specialty pharmacies, also raises concerns about potential conflicts of interest and reduced competition.2 Regulatory bodies, such as the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), have initiated actions concerning PBM market power and its impact on drug prices.1 These investigations and ongoing legislative efforts reflect persistent concerns about whether PBM practices consistently align with the best interests of patients and healthcare payers, particularly regarding risk management and cost control within the pharmaceutical sector.

Pharmacy Benefit Manager vs. Health Insurance Company

While a pharmacy benefit manager (PBM) and a health insurance company both play roles in healthcare financing, their functions are distinct. A health insurance company provides coverage for medical expenses, including hospital stays, doctor visits, and often prescription drugs, for its members. It sets premiums, manages enrollment, and bears the financial risk of healthcare costs.

A PBM, conversely, is typically a third-party company that specializes specifically in managing the prescription drug benefit portion of a health plan. Health insurance companies often outsource this complex task to PBMs. The PBM's primary responsibilities include negotiating drug prices with manufacturers and pharmacies, developing and maintaining the formulary (list of covered drugs), processing prescription claims, and implementing cost-control programs. While they work in close partnership, the health insurance company holds the overall financial risk and provides the broad health coverage, whereas the PBM focuses solely on optimizing the drug benefit.

FAQs

How does a PBM save money?

A PBM primarily saves money through its negotiating power. By representing a large number of health plans and beneficiaries, PBMs can negotiate significant discounts and rebates with pharmaceutical manufacturers in exchange for preferred placement on drug formularies. They also negotiate discounted rates with pharmacies and implement various utilization management tools, such as prior authorizations and step therapy, to ensure patients use the most cost-effective medications.

Do PBMs affect my prescription costs?

Yes, PBMs directly affect your prescription costs. They determine which drugs are on your plan's formulary, influencing your out-of-pocket copayment or deductible. The negotiations PBMs conduct with manufacturers and pharmacies impact the prices your insurance plan pays, which can indirectly affect your premiums and direct costs at the pharmacy counter.

Are all PBMs the same?

No, not all PBMs are the same. While they perform similar core functions, there are differences in their business models, transparency levels, and the types of services they offer. Some PBMs are independent, while others are vertically integrated with large health insurers or retail pharmacy chains. These structural differences can impact how they manage drug benefits and how much savings are passed on to health plans and patients.

What is a drug formulary?

A drug formulary is a list of prescription drugs covered by a health insurance plan or benefit plan. PBMs create and manage these formularies, categorizing drugs into different tiers that correspond to varying patient cost-sharing levels (e.g., generics on a lower-cost tier, specialty drugs on a higher-cost tier). The formulary guides patients and prescribers toward preferred medications that offer clinical effectiveness and cost efficiency.