What Is Post judgment interest?
Post judgment interest is the interest that accru accrues on a monetary judgment from the date it is entered by a court until the debt is fully paid. This financial concept falls under the broader category of Legal Finance, ensuring that the party awarded the judgment, known as the creditor, is compensated for the time value of money lost during the period between the judgment and its ultimate satisfaction. It prevents the debtor from benefiting from delaying payment and serves to encourage prompt payment of the awarded amount. Post judgment interest is distinct from any interest that might have accrued before the judgment was rendered.
History and Origin
The concept of interest on monetary awards has evolved significantly over time. Historically, at common law, courts were often reluctant to grant interest on judgments, viewing it as potentially punitive. However, this stance evolved as legal systems recognized the need to fully compensate judgment creditors for the delay in receiving their awarded funds. Post-judgment interest, as it exists today, is primarily a matter of statutory law rather than common law. Legislatures across jurisdictions have enacted specific statutes to allow for and govern the award of interest on money judgments. This legislative action ensures that a judgment creditor is compensated for the deprivation of the use of their money, particularly during the period an appeal might be pending or payment is otherwise delayed. For instance, an academic paper notes that post-judgment interest did not exist at common law and is solely a matter of legislative grace.4 These statutory rates are often adjusted to align with prevailing interest rates and economic conditions.
Key Takeaways
- Post judgment interest is calculated from the date a court enters a monetary judgment until the judgment is fully paid.
- It serves to compensate the judgment creditor for the time value of money and incentivizes the debtor to pay promptly.
- The rate of post judgment interest is typically set by statute, either at the federal or state level, and can vary.
- Unlike prejudgment interest, post judgment interest is generally mandatory once a money judgment is entered.
- Interest can accumulate significantly, potentially increasing the total amount owed by the debtor over time.
Formula and Calculation
The calculation of post judgment interest is generally straightforward, applying a specified interest rate to the principal amount of the judgment. The interest typically accrues daily and is often compounded annually.
The basic formula for calculating post judgment interest is:
Where:
- (\text{Judgment Amount}) = The total monetary award stated in the judgment.
- (\text{Daily Interest Rate}) = The annual statutory interest rate divided by 365 (or 366 in a leap year).
- (\text{Number of Days}) = The number of days from the date of judgment entry to the date of payment.
Federal courts, for example, calculate post judgment interest at a rate equal to the weekly average 1-year constant maturity Treasury yield, as published by the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, for the calendar week preceding the date of the judgment.3 This rate is then fixed for the duration of the judgment until it is satisfied. Interest is computed daily and is compound interest annually.
Interpreting the Post judgment interest
Interpreting post judgment interest primarily involves understanding its cumulative effect on the total amount owed. For a judgment creditor, it represents an additional form of damages for the delay in receiving their awarded funds. This interest ensures that the value of their award is preserved against inflation and the opportunity cost of not having access to the money. For a judgment debtor, the accumulation of post judgment interest means that delaying payment will result in a higher total financial obligation. It serves as a financial penalty for non-compliance or slow compliance with the court's order. The presence of post judgment interest can also influence decisions regarding an appeal, as continued litigation prolongs the period over which interest accrues. Timely enforcement of judgment becomes crucial for the creditor to halt the accumulation of interest.
Hypothetical Example
Consider a scenario where a plaintiff, Sarah, wins a lawsuit against a defendant, John, and is awarded a judgment of $100,000 on January 1, 2024. The applicable statutory post judgment interest rate in their jurisdiction is 5% per annum, compounded annually.
- Judgment Entry: January 1, 2024, Judgment Amount = $100,000.
- Annual Interest Rate: 5%
- Daily Interest Rate: 5% / 365 = 0.000136986 (approx.)
If John pays the full judgment one year later on January 1, 2025:
- Interest for Year 1 = $100,000 * 0.05 = $5,000
- Total owed at end of Year 1 = $100,000 + $5,000 = $105,000
If John delays payment until January 1, 2026 (two years later), and the interest compounds annually:
- Total owed at end of Year 1 = $105,000
- Interest for Year 2 (on compounded amount) = $105,000 * 0.05 = $5,250
- Total owed at end of Year 2 = $105,000 + $5,250 = $110,250
This example illustrates how post judgment interest can incrementally increase the total amount owed by the debtor over time.
Practical Applications
Post judgment interest is a common feature in civil litigation across various legal and financial contexts. It applies to a wide range of monetary judgments, from personal injury awards and contract disputes to commercial litigation and debt collection cases.
For instance, in the federal court system, 28 U.S.C. § 1961 governs post judgment interest rates in civil cases, typically linking them to the weekly average 1-year constant maturity Treasury yield. This ensures a standardized approach to compensation for delay. Similarly, state laws define their own post judgment interest rates, which can vary significantly. For example, New York enacted the Fair Consumer Judgment Interest Act in 2021, lowering the statutory interest rate on consumer debts to 2% per annum, aiming to aid financially struggling New Yorkers.
2
In personal finance, individuals pursuing a lawsuit should be aware that if they win a monetary judgment, post judgment interest will begin to accrue, increasing the amount they are entitled to. For businesses involved in litigation, understanding post judgment interest is crucial for financial planning and assessing the true cost of an adverse judgment or the full recovery from a favorable one. It also impacts settlement negotiations, as the potential accrual of interest provides an incentive for both parties to resolve disputes promptly. The IRS also publishes IRS quarterly interest rates for underpayments and overpayments, demonstrating a similar concept of applying interest to outstanding financial obligations.
1
Limitations and Criticisms
While post judgment interest serves a vital compensatory purpose, it does have certain limitations and has faced criticism. One limitation is the variation in statutory rates across different jurisdictions. A judgment obtained in one state might accrue interest at a significantly different rate than a judgment in another, leading to potential inequities. Federal rates are generally uniform across federal courts but differ from state rates.
Another point of contention can be the fixed nature of some statutory rates. If a statutory rate remains static for a long period, it might either be excessively high or too low relative to prevailing market interest rates, potentially making the judgment either unduly burdensome for the debtor or insufficiently compensatory for the creditor. For example, some jurisdictions might have historically high fixed rates that do not reflect current economic realities.
Furthermore, the calculation and enforcement of judgment can be complex, especially in cases involving partial payments, multiple debtors, or delays in court processing, which can sometimes lead to disputes over the exact amount of interest owed. While the principle is clear, practical application can involve legal challenges.
Post judgment interest vs. Prejudgment interest
The key distinction between post judgment interest and prejudgment interest lies in the period during which the interest accrues.
| Feature | Post judgment interest | Prejudgment interest |
|---|---|---|
| Accrual Period | From the date the court enters the monetary judgment. | From the time the cause of action arose (e.g., injury, breach). |
| Purpose | Compensates for delay in payment after judgment. | Compensates for loss of use of money before judgment. |
| Mandatory/Discretionary | Generally mandatory once judgment is entered. | Often discretionary, depending on the type of claim and jurisdiction. |
| Calculation | Typically based on statutory rates; fixed from judgment date. | Can be based on statutory rates, contract terms, or court discretion. |
Confusion often arises because both types of interest aim to compensate a party for the time value of money. However, prejudgment interest addresses the period of loss leading up to the legal resolution, while post judgment interest addresses the period of loss after the legal resolution until the debt is satisfied. A victorious plaintiff in a lawsuit may be awarded both types of interest, resulting in a significantly larger total amount than the initial principal sum of damages alone.
FAQs
What is the primary purpose of post judgment interest?
The primary purpose of post judgment interest is to compensate the judgment creditor for the time value of their money that they are deprived of during the period between the entry of a judgment and the actual payment of the funds. It also incentivizes the debtor to pay the judgment promptly.
Is post judgment interest always applied to a judgment?
In most jurisdictions, post judgment interest is statutorily mandated for monetary judgments in civil cases. While the specific rate varies, its application is generally not discretionary once a money judgment is entered by a court.
How is the rate of post judgment interest determined?
The rate of post judgment interest is set by statute, either at the federal level (for federal court judgments) or by individual state legislatures (for state court judgments). These statutory interest rates can be fixed, variable based on economic indicators, or sometimes subject to the terms of a contract between the parties.
Can post judgment interest be waived or negotiated?
While the application of post judgment interest is generally statutory, parties can sometimes negotiate the waiver or alteration of interest as part of a settlement agreement reached after a judgment is entered, especially if it leads to a quicker resolution and payment. However, without such an agreement, the statutory rates apply.
Does post judgment interest use simple or compound interest?
Most jurisdictions specify that post judgment interest accrues daily and often compounds annually. This means that the interest calculated for one period is added to the principal for the next period, leading to compound interest growth over time.