What Are Poverty Thresholds?
Poverty thresholds represent the minimum annual income level that a household needs to afford basic necessities like food, shelter, and clothing within a specific country or region. These thresholds are crucial economic indicators used by governments and international organizations to measure the extent of poverty, track trends over time, and formulate policies aimed at reducing economic hardship. When a household's household income falls below its applicable poverty threshold, all individuals within that household are officially considered to be living in poverty.64
The concept of poverty thresholds helps assess the standard of living and purchasing power of different population segments. These thresholds are adjusted periodically, often annually, to account for changes in the cost of living and inflation.63
History and Origin
The foundational methodology for official poverty thresholds in the United States was developed in the mid-1960s by Mollie Orshansky, an economist at the Social Security Administration.62 Orshansky's approach began with the cost of a minimum food diet, known as the "economy food plan," developed by the U.S. Department of Agriculture.61 Recognizing that food constituted approximately one-third of a typical family's budget at the time, she multiplied the cost of this minimal food plan by three to estimate the total income needed for other expenses.59, 60 This initial framework included various thresholds tailored to different family sizes and compositions, such as the number of children and the age of the household head.58
The U.S. Office of Economic Opportunity adopted Orshansky's thresholds as a working definition of poverty in 1965, coinciding with President Lyndon B. Johnson's "War on Poverty" initiative.56, 57 In 1969, the Bureau of the Budget formalized these thresholds as the federal government's official statistical definition of poverty, with subsequent adjustments primarily linked to the Consumer Price Index (CPI) to account for inflation.54, 55
Key Takeaways
- Poverty thresholds define the minimum income level required for a household to meet basic needs in a given area.53
- They are a key tool for governments and organizations to measure and analyze the prevalence of poverty and income inequality.52
- In the U.S., poverty thresholds were established in the 1960s based on the cost of a minimum food diet, adjusted for family size and inflation.50, 51
- These thresholds are used to classify individuals and families as living in poverty for statistical purposes and to determine eligibility for various social welfare programs.48, 49
- While widely used, poverty thresholds face criticisms for not fully reflecting modern expenses or geographic variations in the cost of living.46, 47
Interpreting Poverty Thresholds
Poverty thresholds provide a statistical benchmark, indicating whether a household's income falls below the minimum deemed necessary for basic subsistence. If a family's total pre-tax cash income is less than their assigned poverty threshold, they are considered to be in poverty.45 The specific dollar amount varies significantly based on family size, the number of children, and sometimes the age of the adults in the household. For example, the threshold for a single individual differs substantially from that for a family of four.44
These thresholds are updated annually to reflect changes in prices, primarily using the Consumer Price Index.43 Despite these adjustments, the interpretation often remains tied to the initial methodology, focusing on basic needs. While not directly a measure of disposable income or wealth, a household's status relative to the poverty threshold provides critical economic data for policymakers and researchers.42
Hypothetical Example
Consider the official poverty thresholds in the United States for a hypothetical year.
Suppose the poverty threshold for a single individual under 65 is \($15,000\). For a family of three (one adult, two children), it is \($25,000\).
-
Scenario 1: Single Individual
- Sarah, aged 30, works part-time and earns an annual household income of \($14,500\).
- Since Sarah's income (\($14,500\)) is below the threshold for a single individual (\($15,000\)), she is considered to be living in poverty.
-
Scenario 2: Family of Three
- Maria, a single mother, lives with her two children. Her total annual income from wages and government assistance is \($26,000\).
- The poverty threshold for a family of three is \($25,000\).
- Since Maria's family income (\($26,000\)) is above their applicable threshold (\($25,000\)), her family is not officially classified as living in poverty, even though their income may still be modest.
This example illustrates how poverty thresholds classify households based on income relative to their specific family structure, impacting their official poverty status.
Practical Applications
Poverty thresholds serve multiple critical functions in policy, social programs, and economic analysis:
- Statistical Measurement: They are primarily used by government agencies, such as the U.S. Census Bureau, to calculate the official poverty rate, track changes in economic growth, and compare poverty levels across different demographic groups and geographic areas.40, 41
- Program Eligibility: Poverty thresholds, often in the form of simplified "poverty guidelines" issued by agencies like the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), determine eligibility for a wide array of federal, state, and local assistance programs.39 These include programs like Medicaid, the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), Head Start, and various housing subsidies.37, 38 For instance, eligibility for SNAP might be set at 130% of the federal poverty line, while Medicaid eligibility could extend to 138% of the poverty line in states that have expanded coverage.35, 36
- Policy Formulation: Governments utilize poverty thresholds as a basis for developing and evaluating fiscal policy aimed at poverty reduction. By understanding the demographic characteristics of those below the threshold, policymakers can design targeted interventions in areas like education, healthcare, and employment support to enhance human capital.
- International Comparisons: Organizations like the World Bank establish international poverty lines to compare poverty levels across countries, using purchasing power parity (PPP) to account for differences in the cost of living globally. The World Bank's current international extreme poverty line is set at \($3.00\) per person per day (in 2021 PPP terms), illustrating a benchmark for extreme deprivation globally.32, 33, 34
Limitations and Criticisms
While poverty thresholds are widely used, they face several significant limitations and criticisms:
- Outdated Methodology: The original methodology, based on a food-cost multiplier from the 1960s, is often criticized for not reflecting modern consumption patterns. Today, expenses such as housing, healthcare, childcare, and transportation often constitute a much larger portion of a household's budget than food.30, 31
- Lack of Geographic Variation: In the United States, official poverty thresholds are generally the same across all contiguous states, despite vast regional differences in the cost of living. For example, the same threshold applies to a family in a rural area with lower expenses as it does to one in a high-cost urban center.28, 29 This can lead to an underestimation of poverty in expensive areas.27
- Exclusion of Non-Cash Benefits and Taxes: The official measure typically considers only pre-tax cash income and does not account for non-cash government benefits (like food assistance or housing vouchers) or the impact of taxes.25, 26 This can lead to an incomplete picture of a household's true financial resources or burdens.
- No Depth of Poverty Measurement: Poverty thresholds are a binary measure; a household is either above or below the line. They do not indicate the severity of poverty, meaning whether a household is just below the threshold or living in deep poverty with very little income.24
- Absolute vs. Relative Poverty: Critics argue that an absolute measure like the poverty threshold may not fully capture the concept of poverty in developed nations, where a relative measure (e.g., income below a certain percentage of the median Gross Domestic Product) might be more appropriate to reflect social exclusion and deprivation relative to the broader population.23 The Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis provides further insight into different methods of measuring poverty and their implications.22
Poverty Thresholds vs. Living Wage
Poverty thresholds and a living wage are both concepts related to income and economic well-being, but they serve different purposes and are calculated differently.
| Feature | Poverty Thresholds | Living Wage |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Statistical measure to define and quantify poverty for policy and analysis. | Hypothetical income needed to afford basic necessities for a modest but adequate standard of living in a specific area, without relying on public assistance.21 |
| Calculation Basis | Historically, a multiple of a minimal food budget, adjusted for family size and inflation.19, 20 | Comprehensive assessment of actual local cost of living for housing, food, childcare, healthcare, transportation, and other essentials.18 |
| Variations | In the U.S., generally uniform across the contiguous states, varying mainly by family size and composition.16, 17 | Varies significantly by geographic location to reflect local expenses.15 |
| Legal Mandate | Not a direct legal mandate for minimum pay; primarily a statistical and program eligibility benchmark. | Not legally mandated as a minimum payment by federal law, though some cities or employers may adopt it. |
| Outcome Goal | Identifies populations living in official poverty. | Aims to provide an income that allows for self-sufficiency and avoids poverty.14 |
The main point of confusion often arises because both terms address the income needed for basic needs. However, a living wage is almost always higher than the poverty threshold because it aims for a more realistic and comfortable standard of living, accounting for a broader range of typical expenses and local economic realities.13
FAQs
What is the primary use of poverty thresholds?
The primary use of poverty thresholds is for statistical purposes, such as estimating the number of people in poverty, tracking poverty trends over time, and comparing poverty rates among different demographic groups. They also serve as a basis for determining eligibility for various federal assistance programs.10, 11, 12
How often are poverty thresholds updated?
Poverty thresholds are typically updated annually to account for inflation, primarily using the Consumer Price Index.8, 9
Do poverty thresholds vary by location within the U.S.?
No, the official poverty thresholds in the U.S. do not vary geographically for the contiguous states. The same thresholds are applied nationwide, differing only by family size and composition, not by variations in the cost of living across different states or cities.6, 7
Are poverty thresholds the same as poverty guidelines?
No, while closely related and based on the same official poverty measure, poverty thresholds and poverty guidelines are distinct. Poverty thresholds are primarily used for statistical purposes by the Census Bureau. Poverty guidelines, issued by the Department of Health and Human Services, are a simplified version of the thresholds used to determine financial eligibility for federal programs.4, 5
What are some common criticisms of poverty thresholds?
Common criticisms include that the thresholds are based on an outdated formula that disproportionately weights food costs, do not account for geographic variations in the cost of living, and do not fully consider non-cash benefits or the impact of taxes.1, 2, 3 This can lead to an underestimation of the true extent of economic hardship.