Reportable accounts

What Are Reportable Accounts?

Reportable accounts are financial accounts subject to specific information-sharing requirements under international tax compliance regulations. These regulations, primarily driven by global efforts against tax evasion, mandate financial institutions to collect and transmit data on accounts held by foreign tax residents to their respective tax authorities. The concept of reportable accounts falls under the broader category of International Finance Regulation and aims to enhance global tax transparency. Such accounts are identified through specific due diligence procedures to ensure that income earned across borders is appropriately declared and taxed in the holder's country of residence.

History and Origin

The framework for reportable accounts largely stems from two significant international initiatives: the U.S. Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA) and the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development’s (OECD) Common Reporting Standard (CRS). FATCA, enacted in 2010 as part of the Hiring Incentives to Restore Employment (HIRE) Act, was a unilateral U.S. law aimed at detecting U.S. taxpayers holding offshore accounts to evade taxes. It compelled foreign financial institutions (FFIs) to report information on U.S. accounts to the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) or face a 30% withholding tax on certain U.S.-sourced payments. FATCA came into effect on July 1, 2014, with widespread international support from nearly 100 jurisdictions. The IRS maintains a dedicated page for the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act, offering comprehensive resources and guidance.
⁴
Following FATCA, the OECD developed the Common Reporting Standard (CRS) in 2014 as a global standard for the Automatic Exchange of Information (AEOI). The CRS built upon FATCA's principles but extended them to a multilateral framework, encouraging widespread adoption among countries to combat tax evasion collaboratively. The OECD's Common Reporting Standard information page provides details on its implementation and assistance.

Key Takeaways

• Reportable accounts are financial accounts that financial institutions must report to tax authorities under international agreements.
• These reporting requirements are designed to combat international tax evasion and enhance financial transparency.
• Key regulatory frameworks include the U.S. Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA) and the OECD's Common Reporting Standard (CRS).
• Financial institutions conduct due diligence to identify reportable accounts based on the account holder's tax residency.
• Non-compliance with reporting obligations can result in significant penalties for financial institutions.

Interpreting Reportable Accounts

Interpreting the concept of reportable accounts involves understanding which accounts fall under the scope of international reporting standards and the implications for both account holders and financial institutions. Essentially, if an account is identified as "reportable," it means that the financial institution holding the account is obligated to provide specific information about it to the tax authorities in the account holder's country of tax residence.

The criteria for what constitutes a reportable account are defined by the specific regulations, such as FATCA or CRS. Generally, they include accounts held by individuals or entities that are tax residents of a participating jurisdiction other than where the financial institution is located. This transparency allows tax authorities to cross-reference reported income and assets with taxpayers' declarations, ensuring greater tax compliance across borders.

Hypothetical Example

Consider an individual, Maria, who is a tax resident of Germany but maintains a savings account with a bank in Switzerland. Under the Common Reporting Standard (CRS), Switzerland is a participating jurisdiction that has committed to exchanging financial information with Germany. Maria's Swiss savings account would be a reportable account.

Here's how it would work:

1. Identification: The Swiss bank, as a financial institution, would identify Maria's account as reportable because she is a tax resident of Germany.
2. Information Gathering: The bank collects specific information about the account, including Maria's name, address, German tax identification number (TIN), account balance, and any income generated (e.g., interest or dividends) during the reporting period.
3. Reporting: The Swiss bank reports this information to the Swiss tax authorities.
4. Exchange: The Swiss tax authorities then automatically exchange this information with the German tax authorities.

This process enables Germany to see details of Maria's account in Switzerland, helping to ensure she properly declares her worldwide income and assets for tax purposes in Germany.

Practical Applications

Reportable accounts have several critical practical applications in the realm of international finance and regulatory compliance:

• Combating Tax Evasion: The primary application is to deter and detect individuals and entities attempting to hide financial assets and income in offshore jurisdictions to avoid tax obligations. The transparency provided by reporting mechanisms significantly reduces opportunities for illicit financial flows.
• Enhancing Global Tax Transparency: Reportable accounts foster a more transparent global financial system, where tax authorities have better visibility into cross-border financial activities. This promotes fairer competition and reduces the appeal of secrecy havens.
• Facilitating Cross-Border Audits: With information on reportable accounts, tax authorities can more effectively conduct audits and investigations into individuals and corporations with international financial dealings, ensuring accurate tax assessment and collection.
• Intergovernmental Cooperation: The existence of reportable accounts necessitates cooperation between countries through Intergovernmental Agreements (IGAs) or multilateral agreements like the CRS, strengthening international collaboration on financial crime and tax matters.

For example, the U.S. Department of the Treasury's FATCA page highlights how the act aims to target non-compliance by U.S. taxpayers using foreign accounts, serving as a cornerstone for practical application of reportable account principles.
³

Limitations and Criticisms

While designed to combat tax evasion, the regime of reportable accounts has faced several limitations and criticisms:

• Privacy Concerns: A significant criticism revolves around the extensive collection and exchange of personal financial data, raising concerns about individual privacy rights. Some argue that the automatic exchange of information, regardless of suspected wrongdoing, can be an overreach. For instance, in May 2023, the Belgian data protection authority reportedly held that the transfer of personal data to the United States under FATCA was illegal, citing incompatibilities with EU law, including GDPR.
• Compliance Burden for Financial Institutions: Foreign financial institutions (FFIs) and other reporting entities bear a substantial administrative and cost burden in implementing the necessary due diligence systems, identifying reportable accounts, and transmitting data securely. This can be particularly challenging for smaller institutions.
• "De-risking" and Financial Exclusion: To avoid the complexities and potential penalties of non-compliance, some financial institutions have resorted to "de-risking," which involves terminating relationships with clients perceived as high-risk, including U.S. citizens abroad. This can lead to financial exclusion for certain individuals or entities, limiting their access to essential banking services.
• Lack of Reciprocity (FATCA specific): A common criticism of FATCA is its perceived unilateral nature, where the U.S. demands extensive information from other countries but does not always provide reciprocal levels of information under the same automatic exchange mechanisms, especially with countries that are part of CRS but not FATCA. ¹This creates an imbalance that some perceive as unfair.

Reportable Accounts vs. Common Reporting Standard (CRS)

While closely related, "Reportable Accounts" and the "Common Reporting Standard (CRS)" are distinct concepts.

In essence, the Common Reporting Standard (CRS) is the international rulebook or standard that dictates which accounts are considered reportable accounts and how the information about them should be exchanged between tax authorities globally. Reportable accounts are the practical manifestation of the accounts identified under the CRS (or FATCA). Without the CRS (or FATCA), the concept of reportable accounts as we understand it in international tax transparency would not exist.

FAQs

What kind of information is reported for a reportable account?

For a reportable account, financial institutions typically report the account holder's name, address, country of residence, tax identification number, account number, account balance or value, and certain types of income paid into the account, such as interest, dividends, and other returns from financial assets.

Who determines if an account is a reportable account?

The financial institution where the account is held is responsible for determining if an account is reportable. They do this by conducting due diligence procedures, which involve collecting information from the account holder about their tax residency and checking for "indicia" (indicators) that suggest tax residency in another country.

Are all foreign accounts considered reportable accounts?

No, not all foreign accounts are automatically considered reportable accounts. An account is reportable if it is held by an individual or entity that is a tax resident of a jurisdiction with which the financial institution's country has an information exchange agreement (like FATCA or CRS), and if it meets certain criteria or thresholds specified in those regulations.

Does having a reportable account mean I am evading taxes?

No, having a reportable account does not mean you are evading taxes. It simply means your financial institution is obligated to report your account information to your country of tax residence. This process helps tax authorities ensure that all taxpayers, including those with overseas accounts, are compliant with their tax compliance obligations. If you are reporting all your worldwide income accurately, you have nothing to worry about.