Returns on capital

What Is Returns on Capital?

Returns on capital represent a crucial set of financial ratios that measure how effectively a company utilizes its invested capital to generate profits. Belonging to the broader category of corporate finance metrics, returns on capital provide insights into a firm's profitability and operational efficiency. These metrics assess the earnings generated relative to the capital employed in the business, reflecting the management's ability to create value from the funds entrusted to them by both debt holders and equity investors. Investors and analysts frequently examine returns on capital to evaluate a company's performance, assess its competitive advantage, and make informed investment decisions.

History and Origin

The concept of evaluating returns on invested resources has roots in early business accounting, as owners and merchants sought to understand the profitability of their ventures. Over time, as businesses grew in complexity and capital structures evolved, more sophisticated metrics were developed to analyze the efficiency of capital utilization. The formalization of financial ratios, including various measures of returns on capital, became more prominent with the rise of modern corporate finance and investment analysis in the 20th century. Academics and practitioners refined these calculations to provide a clearer picture of a company’s ability to generate earnings from its capital base. Research has explored the relationship between the marginal product of capital and financial returns, indicating the enduring academic interest in understanding how capital generates wealth. ⁵The continuous development of financial reporting standards and analytical tools has further cemented the role of returns on capital as a core metric for assessing corporate performance.

Key Takeaways

• Returns on capital measure a company's ability to generate profits from the money invested in its operations.
• Key variations include Return on Invested Capital (ROIC) and Return on Capital Employed (ROCE), each with slightly different capital base definitions.
• A consistently high return on capital indicates efficient management and a strong competitive position.
• These metrics are essential for evaluating capital allocation decisions and comparing the performance of different companies or projects.
• Analysis of returns on capital should always consider industry specificities, a company's growth stage, and its capital structure.

Formula and Calculation

One of the most widely used forms of returns on capital is Return on Invested Capital (ROIC). This metric calculates the after-tax operating profit a company generates for each dollar of capital it has deployed.

The formula for Return on Invested Capital (ROIC) is typically expressed as:

Where:

• NOPAT (Net Operating Profit After Tax) is the company's operating income after taxes, but before interest payments. It reflects the profitability of the company's core operations, independent of its debt financing.
• Invested Capital represents the total capital a company uses to generate its operating income. This typically includes total equity and long-term debt, minus any non-operating cash or investments. It can be calculated as: $$\text{Invested Capital} = \text{Total Assets} - \text{Non-Interest Bearing Current Liabilities}$$ or $$\text{Invested Capital} = \text{Shareholder's Equity} + \text{Total Debt} - \text{Non-Operating Cash}$$ The invested capital considers all the funds that have been committed to the business to generate its operating revenue.

Interpreting the Returns on Capital

Interpreting returns on capital requires context. A high ratio generally suggests that a company is effectively converting its capital into profits, indicating a strong competitive advantage or a well-managed business. Conversely, a low or declining ratio may signal inefficiencies, poor investment decisions, or intense competition within the industry.

When evaluating returns on capital, it is often compared to a company's cost of capital. If returns on capital exceed the cost of capital, the company is said to be creating economic value. If it falls below the cost of capital, the company is destroying value, as it is earning less than the minimum required return for its investors. Furthermore, analysts compare a company's returns on capital to its historical performance, industry averages, and competitors to gain a comprehensive understanding of its relative financial health and operational prowess. For example, a company with an ROIC of 15% in an industry where the average is 10% demonstrates superior capital management.

Hypothetical Example

Consider a hypothetical manufacturing company, "Alpha Corp," that produces widgets.
For the past fiscal year, Alpha Corp reported the following:

• NOPAT: $20 million
• Total Equity: $80 million
• Total Debt: $40 million
• Non-Operating Cash: $5 million

To calculate Alpha Corp's Return on Invested Capital (ROIC):

First, calculate Invested Capital:

Next, calculate ROIC:

This 17.39% ROIC indicates that for every dollar of capital invested in Alpha Corp's operations, the company generated approximately 17.39 cents in after-tax operating profit. If the company's weighted average cost of capital (WACC) is, for instance, 10%, then Alpha Corp is generating returns significantly above its cost of funding, indicating strong value creation.

Practical Applications

Returns on capital are widely used across various aspects of financial analysis and corporate strategy. In equity analysis, investors utilize these metrics to identify companies that are highly effective at utilizing their capital, often seen as indicators of a sustainable competitive advantage. Businesses leverage returns on capital to guide their capital expenditure decisions, ensuring that new projects or expansions promise sufficient returns to justify the investment. Effective capital allocation is deemed critical for long-term corporate success and shareholder value creation.
⁴
For corporate management, returns on capital are vital for internal performance evaluation, helping to pinpoint which business units or product lines are most efficient in their use of resources. This aids in strategic planning and resource allocation. Regulatory bodies, such as the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), require companies to provide detailed discussions on their capital resources and commitments in their Management's Discussion and Analysis (MD&A) sections of financial reports, implicitly emphasizing the importance of efficient capital utilization and returns to investors. ³Understanding returns on capital is also crucial in mergers and acquisitions, as it helps in valuing target companies and assessing the potential for post-acquisition value creation.

Limitations and Criticisms

While valuable, returns on capital metrics have limitations. They are backward-looking, relying on historical financial data from the balance sheet and income statement, and may not accurately predict future performance, especially in rapidly changing industries. Accounting conventions, such as varying methods of depreciation or the treatment of intangible assets, can significantly distort the reported invested capital and, consequently, the returns on capital. ²For instance, older assets that have been largely depreciated may lead to artificially inflated returns, even if the underlying operational efficiency has not improved.

Furthermore, these metrics may not fully capture the value of investments in intangible assets like research and development (R&D) or brand building, which are expensed rather than capitalized. This can penalize companies heavily investing in future growth. External factors such as economic cycles, interest rate changes, or competitive pressures are also not directly incorporated into the ratio itself, necessitating a broader analytical framework. The challenges of using return on capital as an indicator of market power or true economic efficiency have been noted in academic literature, highlighting that accounting rates of return do not always equate to underlying economic returns.
¹

Returns on Capital vs. Return on Investment

While both "returns on capital" and "Return on Investment" (ROI) assess the profitability of an investment, they differ in their scope and the specific "investment" base they consider.

Returns on capital, particularly ROIC, provide a holistic view of a company's ability to generate profits from its operational asset base, irrespective of how that capital is financed. ROI, conversely, is a versatile metric applicable to any singular investment, from a marketing campaign to a real estate purchase, focusing solely on the gain relative to the cost of that specific outlay.

FAQs

What is considered a good return on capital?

A "good" return on capital is relative to the industry, the company's cost of capital, and its historical performance. Generally, a return on capital that consistently exceeds a company's weighted average cost of capital (WACC) indicates that the company is creating value. For many established businesses, an ROIC above 10-15% is often considered strong, but capital-intensive industries might have lower benchmarks, while asset-light industries might achieve much higher returns.

How do changes in capital structure affect returns on capital?

Returns on capital metrics like ROIC are designed to be largely independent of a company's capital structure. By using Net Operating Profit After Tax (NOPAT) as the numerator (which excludes interest expense) and including both debt and equity in invested capital, ROIC aims to show the operational profitability before financing decisions. However, extreme leverage or significant changes in the mix of debt and equity can indirectly affect perceived risk and the cost of capital, which contextualizes the return.

Can returns on capital be negative?

Yes, returns on capital can be negative if a company's Net Operating Profit After Tax (NOPAT) is negative, meaning its core operations are not generating sufficient profit to cover its operating expenses and taxes. A negative return on capital indicates that the company is destroying value and is unable to generate a satisfactory return on the funds invested in its business. This signals severe financial distress.

Why is working capital included in some returns on capital calculations?

Working capital (current assets minus current liabilities) that is directly tied to a company's operations, often referred to as operating working capital, is included in some returns on capital calculations because it represents capital that is necessary to run the day-to-day business and generate revenue. Funds tied up in inventory or accounts receivable are just as much "invested capital" in operations as plant and equipment.