What Is Rights Offerings?
A rights offering is a method of equity financing by which a company grants its existing shareholders the privilege, or "right," to purchase additional shares of the company's common stock proportionally to their current holdings, typically at a discount to the prevailing market price. This corporate finance strategy allows companies to raise capital directly from their existing investor base, often without the need for an investment bank or public roadshow. Rights offerings are a common tool in corporate finance for companies seeking to raise capital while providing their existing shareholders with the opportunity to maintain their proportionate ownership and avoid dilution.
History and Origin
The concept of rights offerings is deeply rooted in the principle of preemptive rights, which historically grants existing shareholders the first opportunity to purchase new shares issued by a company to preserve their percentage ownership. This method of capital raising has been utilized for centuries, predating many modern securities regulations. In the wake of major economic downturns, such as the 2008 global financial crisis, rights offerings saw a resurgence as a means for companies, particularly financial institutions, to shore up their capital structure without resorting to more dilutive or costly forms of financing. For instance, in April 2008, the Royal Bank of Scotland announced a £12 billion rights issue, which was at the time the largest in UK corporate history, as it sought to navigate the unfolding credit crunch.
5
Key Takeaways
- Rights offerings grant existing shareholders the ability to purchase new shares pro rata, typically at a discounted subscription price.
- They serve as a capital-raising mechanism that allows companies to obtain funds directly from their current investor base.
- Existing shareholders can choose to exercise their rights, sell them (if transferable), or let them expire.
- A key benefit is that shareholders who exercise their rights can avoid the immediate dilution of their ownership percentage.
- The terms of a rights offering, including the subscription price and ratio, are set by the issuing company.
Formula and Calculation
Rights offerings involve specific calculations to determine the theoretical ex-rights price (TERP) and the value of a single right.
Theoretical Ex-Rights Price (TERP)
The TERP represents the expected share price after the rights offering, assuming all rights are exercised. It reflects the blended value of the existing shares and the new, lower-priced shares.
Where:
- (N) = Number of existing shares required to buy one new share (rights ratio)
- (MP) = Current market price per share
- (S) = Number of new shares offered (usually 1 for the ratio)
- (SP) = Subscription price per new share
Value of a Right
The value of a right indicates the intrinsic value of each individual right issued to shareholders.
Alternatively:
Where:
- (MP) = Current market price per share
- (SP) = Subscription price per new share
- (N) = Number of existing shares required to buy one new share (rights ratio)
Interpreting the Rights Offerings
Interpreting a rights offering involves understanding its implications for both the issuing company and its shareholders. For the company, a rights offering signifies a need or desire to raise additional share capital. The discounted subscription price is designed to incentivize participation by existing investors. For shareholders, the rights offering presents a choice: subscribe to maintain their proportionate ownership, sell their rights (if transferable) to profit from their value, or allow them to expire. Not participating leads to a proportionate reduction in ownership, also known as dilution, even if the total value of their holdings remains theoretically the same if the market price adjusts accordingly on the ex-rights date.
Hypothetical Example
Consider XYZ Corp., which has 10 million shares outstanding trading at a market price of $50 per share. XYZ Corp. announces a rights offering to raise capital for expansion. The terms are: one new share can be purchased for every four existing shares held (1-for-4 rights ratio) at a subscription price of $40.
A shareholder owning 400 shares of XYZ Corp. would receive 100 rights (400 shares / 4). Each right allows them to buy one new share at $40.
If they exercise all their rights, they will invest $4,000 (100 shares * $40) and increase their holding to 500 shares.
Let's calculate the Theoretical Ex-Rights Price (TERP):
Current total value before rights = 400 shares * $50 = $20,000
Investment from rights = 100 shares * $40 = $4,000
New total shares = 400 + 100 = 500 shares
New total value = $20,000 + $4,000 = $24,000
TERP = $24,000 / 500 shares = $48 per share.
Alternatively, using the formula:
TERP = ((4 * $50) + (1 * $40)) / (4 + 1) = ($200 + $40) / 5 = $240 / 5 = $48.
The value of each right is $50 (current market price) - $48 (TERP) = $2 per right.
This indicates the value conferred to each right received by the shareholder.
Practical Applications
Rights offerings are primarily used by companies to raise capital without taking on additional debt or undergoing a full underwriting process with an investment bank that might be more costly or difficult in certain market conditions. They are particularly attractive to companies that wish to maintain a strong relationship with their existing shareholders and offer them a priority stake in future growth. This method can be seen in various sectors, from mature industries looking to finance expansion or pay down debt, to companies in distressed situations seeking a capital injection. Rights offerings are often structured to be "backstopped" by a major investor or group of investors, ensuring the offering is fully subscribed even if some existing shareholders do not participate. This backstop commitment acts as a guarantee for the issuer.
4
Furthermore, the listing of rights themselves on exchanges can facilitate secondary trading, providing liquidity to shareholders who do not wish to exercise their rights but prefer to sell them. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has specific regulations concerning rights offerings, particularly for foreign private issuers, aimed at ensuring equal treatment for U.S. holders.
3
Limitations and Criticisms
While rights offerings offer clear advantages, they also come with limitations and criticisms. One primary concern is the potential for dilution for shareholders who do not exercise their rights. Even though the theoretical value of their holdings should remain the same immediately after the offering, the decrease in their proportional ownership and potential decline in earnings per share (EPS) can be perceived negatively. The perception that a company is undertaking a rights offering due to financial distress rather than growth opportunities can also lead to negative market sentiment and downward pressure on the share price.
2
Some academic studies have explored the impact of rights issues on market price performance, with findings suggesting that greater discounts offered in rights issues may have a slight adverse effect on shareholders in the short term following an announcement. 1Additionally, if the market price falls significantly below the subscription price during the offering period, it can make the rights offering unattractive, potentially leading to a large number of unsubscribed shares unless a strong standby commitment is in place. Companies must also manage the logistical complexities, including adhering to specific notification requirements regarding the record date and offering period.
Rights offerings vs. Public offering
Rights offerings and a public offering are both methods of issuing new shares, but they differ significantly in their target audience and process. A rights offering exclusively targets a company's existing shareholders, giving them the preemptive right to purchase new shares pro rata. This approach aims to minimize dilution for those who participate and often comes with a discounted subscription price.
In contrast, a public offering (often an initial public offering or a seasoned equity offering) makes new shares available to the broader investing public, including new investors. These offerings typically involve an underwriting syndicate of investment banks, extensive marketing, and can be more costly and time-consuming. While a public offering aims to cast a wider net for capital, it does not prioritize existing shareholders and can lead to immediate dilution of their ownership percentage if they do not purchase additional shares in the open market.
FAQs
What does "rights expire worthless" mean?
If a shareholder chooses not to exercise their rights and does not sell them before the expiration date, the rights become null and void. They hold no value and cannot be converted into shares, effectively becoming "worthless."
Can rights offerings include other securities besides common stock?
While most commonly associated with common stock, a rights offering can occasionally allow shareholders to subscribe for other securities, such as preferred stock or warrants, depending on the terms set by the issuing company.
Do rights offerings always provide a discount?
Yes, typically a rights offering includes a subscription price that is at a discount to the prevailing market price of the stock. This discount serves as an incentive for existing shareholders to participate and provides value to the rights themselves.
How do rights offerings affect dividends?
A rights offering itself does not directly change a company's dividend policy. However, if the company issues a large number of new shares, it could dilute the earnings per share, which might influence future dividend payout ratios, although this is a separate corporate decision.