S corporations

What Are S Corporations?

S corporations are a type of business structure that provides the limited liability protections of a corporation while offering the tax benefits of a pass-through entity. This means that instead of the business paying corporate income tax at the entity level, the profits and losses are passed directly through to the personal income of the company's shareholders. S corporations fall under the broader category of business structures within financial management, specifically relating to corporate taxation and legal formation. The designation "S corporation" comes from Subchapter S of the Internal Revenue Code, which outlines the specific rules and requirements for this election.

History and Origin

Before the advent of S corporations, businesses seeking corporate limited liability often faced "double taxation," where corporate profits were taxed at the corporate level and again when distributed to shareholders as dividends. To alleviate this burden, the U.S. Congress, acting on a suggestion from the Department of Treasury, created the "Subchapter S" election in 1958 as part of a package of tax reforms. This initial legislation aimed to allow small businesses to enjoy the benefits of corporate status without incurring the full tax implications of traditional corporations. A significant revision occurred with the Subchapter S Revision Act of 1982, which simplified and modified many of the rules regarding eligibility, income, and distributions for S corporations. This act, for instance, increased the maximum number of shareholders an S corporation could have and specified that differences in voting rights among common stock would not lead to disqualification¹⁸.

Key Takeaways

• S corporations avoid federal double taxation by passing income, losses, deductions, and credits directly to shareholders' personal tax returns.
• Shareholders of S corporations benefit from limited liability protection, similar to traditional corporations.
• S corporations must adhere to specific eligibility requirements set by the IRS, including limits on the number and type of shareholders.
• Owners who work for the S corporation must pay themselves a "reasonable salary" subject to payroll taxes before taking additional distributions.
• The S corporation structure is often favored by small business owners seeking tax efficiencies.

Formula and Calculation

While there isn't a single "formula" for an S corporation itself, the key financial concept revolves around the calculation of a shareholder's taxable income and the basis in their stock. The income or loss of an S corporation flows through to the shareholders' individual tax returns based on their proportionate ownership.

For a shareholder, their share of the S corporation's ordinary business income (or loss) and separately stated items is calculated as:

For example, if an S corporation has $100,000 in net income and a shareholder owns 25% of the company, their share of the income would be $25,000. This amount is then reported on their personal tax return (Form 1040, Schedule K-1).

The shareholder's basis in their S corporation stock is adjusted annually. It starts with their initial capital contribution and is increased by their share of income and additional contributions, and decreased by distributions and their share of losses. The basis calculation is crucial because distributions are generally tax-free up to the amount of the shareholder's stock basis.

Interpreting S Corporations

Interpreting an S corporation primarily involves understanding its unique tax treatment compared to other business structures. The primary interpretation is that the business itself generally does not pay federal income tax. Instead, the tax burden shifts to the individual shareholders. This "pass-through" characteristic is a key differentiator from C corporations, which are subject to double taxation—once at the corporate level and again when dividends are distributed to shareholders.

For business owners, electing S corporation status often signifies a strategic decision to minimize the overall tax liability on business profits, particularly for profitable ventures where owners take distributions in addition to salaries. However, this interpretation must also consider the stringent requirements and compliance obligations, such as the need for a "reasonable salary" for shareholder-employees to prevent reclassification of distributions by the IRS.

Hypothetical Example

Consider "GreenThumb Landscaping LLC," a small business owned by Sarah. After consulting with her accountant, Sarah decides to elect S corporation status to reduce her self-employment tax burden.

In 2024, GreenThumb Landscaping LLC, operating as an S corporation, generates $150,000 in net profit. Sarah works full-time in the business. Based on industry standards for her role and services provided, her accountant advises her to pay herself a "reasonable salary" of $60,000. This salary is subject to regular payroll taxes (Social Security and Medicare), just like any other employee's wages.

The remaining $90,000 of the S corporation's profit ($150,000 - $60,000) is considered a pass-through distribution. This $90,000 passes through to Sarah's personal tax return but is generally not subject to self-employment taxes. Sarah reports both her $60,000 salary (on a W-2) and the $90,000 pass-through income (on a Schedule K-1, attached to her Form 1120-S for the business) on her individual income tax return (Form 1040). This allows her to potentially lower her overall tax burden compared to if the entire $150,000 was subject to self-employment taxes as a sole proprietorship or partnership.

Practical Applications

S corporations are widely applied in various contexts, primarily by small business owners and closely held companies seeking tax advantages. Their primary application lies in reducing the tax burden associated with self-employment taxes. By paying a "reasonable salary" to owner-employees and taking remaining profits as distributions, S corporation owners can avoid paying Social Security and Medicare taxes on the entire business profit.
¹⁷
They are frequently used by:

• Service-based Businesses: Consultants, freelancers, and professional service providers often form S corporations to manage their tax liabilities.
• Entrepreneurs: New ventures can leverage the S corporation structure to attract initial investments while providing tax efficiency for early profits.
• Real Estate Investors: Individuals holding investment properties through an S corporation can sometimes optimize their tax situation.

The U.S. Small Business Administration (SBA) notes that S corporations allow profits and some losses to be passed directly to owners' personal income without ever being subject to corporate income tax rates. ¹⁶For tax reporting, S corporations file Form 1120-S with the IRS annually.
¹⁵

Limitations and Criticisms

Despite their advantages, S corporations come with several limitations and potential criticisms. The most notable restrictions involve eligibility:

• Shareholder Limits: An S corporation generally cannot have more than 100 shareholders, and certain types of entities, like partnerships, corporations, and non-resident aliens, are typically not allowed as shareholders.
  ¹⁴* One Class of Stock: S corporations can generally only have one class of stock, though differences in voting rights are permitted. This limits flexibility in equity structuring compared to C corporations, which can issue multiple classes of stock.
• Reasonable Compensation: A significant area of scrutiny from the IRS is the "reasonable compensation" rule. S corporation owners who also work for the company must pay themselves a salary that is "the value that would ordinarily be paid for like services by like enterprises under like circumstances". ¹³If the IRS determines that a shareholder-employee's salary is unreasonably low to avoid payroll taxes, they can reclassify distributions as wages, leading to potential fines and penalties for underpayment of employment taxes. ¹²This adds a layer of complexity and potential audit risk for S corporation owners.
• Loss Limitations: While losses can pass through to shareholders, they are generally limited to the shareholder's stock basis plus any direct loans made to the corporation. This can limit the immediate tax benefit of losses if a shareholder has insufficient basis.
• Fringe Benefits: The tax treatment of fringe benefits for S corporation shareholders owning more than 2% of the company can be less favorable than for C corporation employees, as these benefits may be treated as taxable income to the shareholder.

S Corporations vs. C Corporations

The key distinction between S corporations and C corporations lies primarily in their tax treatment and, to a lesser extent, their ownership structure. Both provide limited liability protection to their owners, meaning personal assets are generally shielded from business debts and lawsuits. ¹¹Both also require formal incorporation at the state level by filing articles of incorporation and maintaining corporate formalities, such as electing a board of directors.
¹⁰
However, the significant difference is taxation. C corporations are subject to double taxation: the corporation pays corporate income tax on its profits, and then shareholders pay individual income tax on any dividends they receive. ⁹S corporations, on the other hand, avoid this double taxation because profits and losses are passed directly through to the shareholders' personal tax returns, where they are taxed only once.
⁸
Beyond taxation, S corporations have stricter limitations on the number and type of shareholders (e.g., typically limited to 100 U.S. citizens or residents) and can generally only have one class of stock. C corporations have no such restrictions on the number or type of shareholders and can issue multiple classes of stock, making them more suitable for attracting a wide range of investors or preparing for a public offering. ⁶, ⁷The choice between the two often depends on the business's size, growth trajectory, and specific tax planning goals.

FAQs

What is the main tax advantage of an S corporation?

The primary tax advantage of an S corporation is avoiding double taxation. Business profits are not taxed at the corporate level; instead, they "pass through" directly to the owners' personal tax returns, where they are taxed only once. ⁵This can also lead to lower payroll taxes for owner-employees, as distributions (beyond a "reasonable salary") are not subject to Social Security and Medicare taxes.

Can an LLC be taxed as an S corporation?

Yes, a limited liability company (LLC) can elect to be taxed as an S corporation. By default, an LLC is taxed as a sole proprietorship (if one owner) or a partnership (if multiple owners). However, an LLC can file Form 2553 with the IRS to elect S corporation status, combining the structural flexibility of an LLC with the tax benefits of an S corporation.
⁴

What is a "reasonable salary" for an S corporation owner?

A "reasonable salary" is the compensation that the IRS requires an S corporation owner-employee to pay themselves for the services they provide to the business. The IRS defines it as "the value that would ordinarily be paid for like services by like enterprises under like circumstances". ³There's no specific formula, but factors like training, experience, duties, and salaries paid to non-shareholder employees in similar roles are considered. ²This salary is subject to employment taxes, while remaining profits taken as distributions are not.

How do S corporation distributions affect a shareholder's tax?

Distributions from an S corporation are generally tax-free to the extent of a shareholder's stock basis. Any distributions exceeding the shareholder's basis are typically treated as capital gains. ¹It's crucial for shareholders to track their basis to correctly report distributions and avoid unexpected tax liabilities, especially when their adjusted gross income is high.