What Are Share based payments?
Share based payments refer to a form of non-cash compensation provided by a company to its employees, directors, or other service providers, where the value of the compensation is based on the company's Equity or other equity instruments. This practice falls under the broader umbrella of Accounting and Corporate Finance, as it significantly impacts a company's financial statements and capital structure. Companies use share based payments as a means of Incentive compensation to align the interests of recipients with those of shareholders, promoting long-term growth and value creation. The recognition of the associated Compensation expense is a crucial aspect of accounting for share based payments, requiring careful valuation and expense attribution over the service period.
History and Origin
The accounting for share based payments has evolved significantly, particularly with the introduction of rigorous Accounting standards. Historically, many companies were not required to recognize the cost of certain share-based compensation, such as Stock options, as an expense on their Income statement. This practice often led to concerns about inflated earnings. In response to growing public and regulatory pressure for greater transparency, the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) issued Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 123 (SFAS 123) in 1995, encouraging, but not requiring, companies to expense stock options at their Fair value. The debate intensified, leading to the issuance of SFAS 123 (revised 2004), known as FAS 123R, which mandated the expensing of all share-based compensation based on their fair value. This new regulation dramatically changed the landscape of compensation accounting.7,6 The principles of FAS 123R were later codified into Accounting Standards Codification (ASC) 718, which now governs the accounting for share based payments for all entities in the United States.5,4
Key Takeaways
- Share based payments are a form of non-cash compensation tied to a company's equity value.
- They are used to incentivize employees, aligning their interests with shareholders and fostering long-term Employee retention.
- Companies are required to recognize the fair value of these awards as an expense on their Income statement over the Vesting period.
- While they don't involve immediate cash outflow, share based payments can impact Dilution and Earnings per share.
- Accounting for share based payments requires complex valuation methods and careful financial reporting.
Formula and Calculation
The accounting for share based payments generally involves calculating the Compensation expense to be recognized over the Vesting period. While there isn't a single universal formula for "share based payments" as a whole, the expense for each award type (like Stock options or Restricted stock units) is determined based on its Fair value at the Grant date.
For equity-classified awards, the total compensation cost is typically calculated as:
This total cost is then allocated systematically over the requisite service period (usually the vesting period), often using a straight-line method. The periodic expense recognized would be:
For awards with performance or market conditions, the determination of awards expected to vest and their fair value can involve more complex probability assessments and valuation models, such as the Black-Scholes-Merton model for options.
Interpreting Share based payments
Interpreting share based payments involves understanding their impact on a company's financial health and shareholder value. From a financial reporting perspective, the expense associated with share based payments reduces reported net income, which can affect profitability metrics and Earnings per share. Even though it is a non-cash expense, its impact on the Income statement is significant.
Analysts and investors often scrutinize the amount of share based payments because of their potential for Dilution to existing shareholders. When these awards vest and are exercised or settled, new shares may be issued, increasing the total number of outstanding shares. This increase can reduce each existing shareholder's proportional ownership. Furthermore, the volume and terms of share based payments can provide insight into a company's compensation philosophy, its efforts in Employee retention, and its long-term strategic outlook.
Hypothetical Example
Imagine TechCorp grants 100 Restricted stock units (RSUs) to an employee on January 1, 2025 (the Grant date). Each RSU represents the right to receive one share of TechCorp stock after a three-year Vesting period, provided the employee remains with the company. On the grant date, TechCorp's stock trades at $50 per share.
- Determine Total Compensation Cost: The Fair value of each RSU at the grant date is $50.
- Total Compensation Cost = 100 RSUs × $50/Rsu = $5,000.
- Allocate Expense over Vesting Period: The $5,000 will be recognized as Compensation expense over three years.
- Annual Expense = $5,000 / 3 years = $1,666.67 per year.
TechCorp would record an expense of $1,666.67 on its income statement for each of the years 2025, 2026, and 2027. At the end of the vesting period in 2028, assuming the employee met the service condition, the employee would receive 100 shares of TechCorp stock. This example demonstrates how the cost of share based payments is spread out over the period in which the company receives the benefit of the employee's service.
Practical Applications
Share based payments are a ubiquitous feature in modern corporate finance, primarily serving as a key component of Incentive compensation and Employee retention strategies, especially in high-growth industries like technology. Companies frequently use various forms, including Stock options, Restricted stock units, and employee stock purchase plans, to attract top talent without incurring immediate cash outflows. From an analytical perspective, understanding a company's share based payments is crucial when evaluating its financial statements. While the expense is non-cash, it affects profitability reported on the Income statement and can lead to future share Dilution. Analysts often adjust reported earnings to better reflect the underlying cash profitability, but they must also consider the ongoing cost of these programs. The Corporate Finance Institute provides insights into how stock-based compensation is accounted for and its implications in financial modeling and analysis. 3Furthermore, regulatory bodies, such as the SEC, issue guidance (like Staff Accounting Bulletin 120, which addresses "spring-loaded awards") that impacts the accounting and disclosure of share based payments, highlighting their significance in corporate governance and transparency.
2
Limitations and Criticisms
Despite their widespread use, share based payments are subject to several limitations and criticisms. A primary concern revolves around their impact on reported profitability. Because the Compensation expense is non-cash, some critics argue that it is overlooked by investors, potentially inflating perceptions of a company's cash-generating ability, even though it reduces reported net income and Earnings per share. This can lead to a disconnect between a company's accounting profits and its actual cash flows, which requires careful analysis of the Statement of cash flows.
Another significant criticism centers on shareholder Dilution. When share based payments vest, new shares are often issued, increasing the total share count and potentially diluting the ownership percentage and voting power of existing shareholders. This can be particularly contentious in companies with substantial ongoing equity compensation programs. The accounting for share based payments also involves complex Fair value estimations, particularly for Stock options, which rely on assumptions that can introduce volatility and subjectivity into financial reporting. Historically, the introduction of FAS 123R (now ASC 718) to mandate expensing was met with significant controversy, with some arguing about the difficulty of valuation and potential negative economic consequences for companies.
1
Share based payments vs. Stock options
Share based payments is a broad term encompassing any form of compensation whose value is derived from the company's shares or other equity instruments. It includes a variety of awards such as Stock options, Restricted stock units (RSUs), stock appreciation rights (SARs), and employee stock purchase plans (ESPPs).
Stock options, on the other hand, are a specific type of share based payment. They grant the recipient the right, but not the obligation, to purchase a company's stock at a predetermined price (the exercise price) within a certain period. While all stock options are share based payments, not all share based payments are stock options. For instance, RSUs directly give the recipient shares upon vesting, whereas stock options require an exercise to obtain shares. The accounting treatment for valuing and expensing each type of share based payment varies slightly, though all fall under the principles of ASC 718.
FAQs
How do share based payments affect a company's financial statements?
Share based payments are recognized as a Compensation expense on the company's Income statement, reducing net income and, consequently, Earnings per share. While they are a non-cash expense, they impact the Balance sheet by increasing equity and are added back to net income when calculating cash flows from operations on the Statement of cash flows.
Are share based payments always given to employees?
No, while most commonly associated with employee compensation, share based payments can also be granted to non-employees, such as directors, consultants, or other service providers, in exchange for goods or services. The Accounting standards (ASC 718) cover both employee and non-employee awards.
How is the value of share based payments determined?
The value of share based payments is generally determined at the Grant date using a Fair value-based measure. For Stock options, companies often use option-pricing models (like Black-Scholes-Merton), while for Restricted stock units, the fair value is typically the market price of the underlying shares on the grant date.
Do share based payments result in cash outflow for the company?
The recognition of the expense for share based payments does not directly result in a cash outflow at the time of recognition. It is a non-cash expense. However, if the awards are cash-settled or if the company repurchases shares to mitigate Dilution, there can be a cash impact. Additionally, related tax benefits can affect cash flows.
What is the primary purpose of using share based payments?
The primary purpose of share based payments is to provide Incentive compensation that aligns the interests of the recipient with the company's long-term success. By making recipients partial owners or giving them a stake in the company's equity, these payments encourage them to contribute to increasing shareholder value and also serve as a powerful tool for Employee retention.