Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to T Definitions

Tax carryback

What Is Tax Carryback?

Tax carryback is a provision in tax laws that allows a business or individual to apply a current year's net operating loss (NOL) to offset taxable income from previous tax years, thereby potentially reducing prior tax liability and generating a refunds. This mechanism falls under the broader category of taxation and is a critical tool in financial management for entities experiencing significant losses. The primary intent of a tax carryback is to provide tax relief and normalize the tax burden over several periods, acknowledging that profitability can fluctuate significantly, especially during challenging business cycles.

History and Origin

The concept of using losses to offset income from other years has a long history in U.S. tax law. The ability to carry back and carry forward losses was first introduced with the Revenue Act of 1918, which allowed for a one-year carryback and a one-year carryforward.10 Over time, the specific periods for tax carryback and carryforward have varied significantly due to legislative changes. For instance, before the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) of 2017, the general rule allowed for net operating losses to be carried back for up to two years and carried forward for up to 20 years.9

The TCJA, enacted in 2017, significantly altered these rules, generally eliminating the ability to carry back most net operating losses and instead allowing for indefinite carryforwards, albeit with a limitation on how much taxable income they could offset annually. However, in response to the economic impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act of 2020 temporarily reinstated a special five-year tax carryback period for NOLs incurred in tax years beginning in 2018, 2019, and 2020. This temporary change also suspended the limitation on the percentage of taxable income that could be offset by NOLs for those years.7, 8 These temporary provisions allowed businesses to amend prior tax returns and claim immediate refunds. Currently, for most taxpayers, NOLs arising in tax years after 2020 cannot be carried back, with some exceptions for specific types of losses like certain farming losses.6

Key Takeaways

  • A tax carryback allows businesses and individuals to use a current year's net operating loss to reduce taxable income from previous years.
  • The primary benefit is a potential refund of taxes paid in prior profitable years, offering immediate cash flow and liquidity.
  • Tax carryback provisions aim to smooth out the tax burden for entities with volatile income, promoting economic efficiency.
  • U.S. federal tax laws regarding tax carrybacks have changed frequently, notably with the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 and the temporary provisions of the CARES Act of 2020.
  • Currently, for most taxpayers, net operating losses arising after 2020 cannot be carried back but can be carried forward indefinitely, subject to certain limitations.

Formula and Calculation

The calculation of a net operating loss (NOL) involves determining the excess of allowable tax deductions over gross income for a given tax year. While there isn't a single "tax carryback formula," the process involves calculating the NOL first, and then applying it to prior years' taxable income according to the prevailing tax laws.

For a simplified illustration, an NOL is generally defined as:

NOL=Deductions−Gross Income\text{NOL} = \text{Deductions} - \text{Gross Income}

Where:

  • (\text{NOL}) = Net Operating Loss
  • (\text{Deductions}) = Total allowable tax deductions for the year
  • (\text{Gross Income}) = Total gross income for the year

If the result is negative, it represents an NOL. This loss is then carried back to eligible prior years, starting with the earliest available year, to reduce the taxable income of those years. The amount of tax carryback utilized cannot reduce the prior year's taxable income below zero. Any unused portion of the NOL would then be carried forward to subsequent years.

Interpreting the Tax Carryback

Interpreting the tax carryback provision primarily revolves around its utility in managing a business's or individual's tax liability and financial stability. When a taxpayer experiences a net operating loss, the ability to carry that loss back provides a mechanism to recover taxes previously paid. This effectively averages out profits and losses over a period, rather than taxing each year in isolation.

For instance, if a company had significant profits and paid substantial corporate tax in previous years, a current year's loss can be used to reclaim a portion of those taxes. This provides immediate tax relief and helps stabilize the company's financial position during downturns. The specifics of how far back a loss can be carried (the carryback period) and what percentage of prior income it can offset are crucial for tax planning and vary based on current tax legislation.

Hypothetical Example

Consider XYZ Corp., a manufacturing company that reported the following taxable income (loss) over several years:

  • Year 1: $1,000,000 (Taxable Income)
  • Year 2: $750,000 (Taxable Income)
  • Year 3: ($2,000,000) (Net Operating Loss)

Assume that under specific, temporary tax laws, a five-year tax carryback is permitted, and the company is subject to a 21% flat corporate tax rate.

  1. Calculate Initial Taxes Paid:

    • Year 1: ( $1,000,000 \times 0.21 = $210,000 )
    • Year 2: ( $750,000 \times 0.21 = $157,500 )

  2. Apply Tax Carryback from Year 3: XYZ Corp. has a $2,000,000 NOL in Year 3.

    • First, the NOL is carried back to the earliest eligible year, which is Year 1 in this simplified scenario (assuming no earlier profitable years within the five-year window).
    • Year 1 taxable income: $1,000,000.
    • Apply $1,000,000 of the Year 3 NOL to Year 1.
    • Remaining NOL: ( $2,000,000 - $1,000,000 = $1,000,000 )
    • Year 1 revised taxable income: ( $1,000,000 - $1,000,000 = $0 )
    • Year 1 tax refund: ( $210,000 )

  3. Continue Applying Remaining NOL:

    • Next, the remaining $1,000,000 NOL is carried back to Year 2.
    • Year 2 taxable income: $750,000.
    • Apply $750,000 of the remaining NOL to Year 2.
    • Remaining NOL: ( $1,000,000 - $750,000 = $250,000 )
    • Year 2 revised taxable income: ( $750,000 - $750,000 = $0 )
    • Year 2 tax refund: ( $157,500 )

  4. Result:
    XYZ Corp. receives total tax refunds of ( $210,000 + $157,500 = $367,500 ). The remaining $250,000 NOL from Year 3 would then typically be carried forward to offset future taxable income. This demonstrates how a tax carryback can provide significant tax relief and improve a company's financial position.

Practical Applications

Tax carryback provisions have significant practical applications for various entities, particularly in managing periods of economic downturn or unexpected losses. Businesses and individuals with fluctuating income streams often benefit from these rules.

  • Business Continuity: For new businesses or those in cyclical industries, a tax carryback can provide crucial cash flow during unprofitable periods by allowing them to recover taxes paid in prior profitable years. This can be vital for survival and investment.
  • Tax Planning Strategy: Companies use tax carryback provisions as part of their broader tax planning strategies. By understanding the rules, they can optimize the utilization of net operating losses to minimize overall tax burdens over time.
  • Economic Stabilization: From a macroeconomic perspective, tax carrybacks can act as automatic stabilizers during recessions, as they provide immediate refunds to businesses that are struggling, potentially stimulating spending and investment.
  • Compliance and Filings: Taxpayers claiming a tax carryback must typically file amended tax returns (such as IRS Form 1045 for individuals, estates, and trusts, or Form 1139 for corporations) for the prior years. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) provides guidance and frequently asked questions regarding these processes.5 Furthermore, detailed rules for net operating losses, including carryback provisions and limitations, are outlined in official IRS publications.4

Limitations and Criticisms

Despite their benefits, tax carryback provisions also come with limitations and have faced criticisms, leading to their frequent modification in tax policy.

One significant limitation is the variable nature of the rules. As seen with the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) of 2017 and the CARES Act of 2020, the eligibility, duration of the carryback period, and the percentage of income that can be offset have changed frequently. This creates uncertainty for long-term tax planning and can complicate compliance for taxpayers. For most taxpayers, NOLs generated after 2020 are no longer eligible for carryback, shifting the focus entirely to carryforwards with an 80% income limitation.3

Critics argue that while tax carrybacks provide tax relief to struggling businesses, they can also reduce federal revenue. Legislative bodies often weigh the economic stimulus benefits against the cost to the treasury. For example, changes to net operating loss provisions by the TCJA were projected to raise significant federal revenues.2 Additionally, complex rules and exceptions, such as those related to specific industries (e.g., farming losses) or certain types of transactions, can make applying tax carryback provisions challenging and may require specialized expertise.

Some argue that carrybacks might disproportionately benefit larger, more established companies with a history of profits to offset, potentially providing less direct support to nascent businesses without prior taxable income. The policy debate surrounding net operating loss provisions, including carrybacks, often centers on balancing the goal of economic efficiency and fairness with revenue considerations.1

Tax Carryback vs. Tax Carryforward

Tax carryback and tax carryforward are two distinct but related mechanisms for utilizing a net operating loss (NOL). The fundamental difference lies in the direction the loss is applied. A tax carryback allows an NOL to be applied to past tax years to reduce previously reported taxable income and potentially generate a refunds of taxes paid. This provides immediate liquidity. In contrast, a tax carryforward allows an NOL to be applied to future tax years to reduce future taxable income. While a carryforward does not provide immediate cash, it reduces future tax liability over subsequent profitable periods. Current U.S. federal tax law for most taxpayers generally disallows tax carrybacks for NOLs incurred after 2020, emphasizing an indefinite tax carryforward period, typically limited to offsetting 80% of future taxable income.

FAQs

1. What is the main purpose of a tax carryback?

The main purpose of a tax carryback is to allow businesses or individuals who incur a net operating loss (NOL) to use that loss to reduce their taxable income from previous profitable years. This can result in a refunds of taxes previously paid, providing immediate cash flow and helping to stabilize finances during difficult periods.

2. Are tax carrybacks currently allowed in the U.S. for most businesses?

For most taxpayers in the U.S., federal tax law generally does not allow a tax carryback for net operating losses incurred in tax years beginning after December 31, 2020. There are limited exceptions, such as for certain farming losses. Instead, businesses typically carry forward their net operating losses indefinitely to offset future taxable income, usually limited to 80% of taxable income in any given year.

3. How has the tax carryback rule changed recently?

The rules for tax carrybacks have changed significantly. The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) of 2017 generally eliminated tax carrybacks. However, the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act of 2020 temporarily and retroactively reinstated a five-year tax carryback period for losses arising in 2018, 2019, and 2020. This temporary provision expired, and current law has largely reverted to disallowing carrybacks for most new losses.