Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to T Definitions

Tax loss carrybacks

What Is Tax Loss Carrybacks?

Tax loss carrybacks refer to a provision in tax law that allows a business or individual to apply a current year's net operating loss (NOL) against taxable income from previous years. This effectively reduces the previously reported taxable income for those past years, potentially leading to a refund of taxes already paid. The concept falls under the broader category of taxation and is a critical component of corporate tax and individual income tax planning, providing a mechanism for taxpayers to smooth out income volatility across different periods. By utilizing tax loss carrybacks, entities can recover taxes paid in profitable years when they experience losses, thereby improving cash flow and profitability during challenging times.

History and Origin

The ability to use losses to offset income earned in other years has a long history in U.S. tax policy, with roots tracing back to the Revenue Act of 1918, which initially allowed for a one-year carryback and one-year carryforward period for losses. Since then, the specific periods for tax loss carrybacks and carryforwards have evolved significantly through various legislative changes. For instance, prior to 2018, general NOL rules typically allowed for losses to be carried back for two years and forward for 20 years.12

However, the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) of 2017 brought substantial changes, generally disallowing tax loss carrybacks for most taxpayers, with limited exceptions for certain farming losses.11 This policy was temporarily reversed by the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act in March 2020. The CARES Act retroactively permitted NOLs generated in tax years 2018, 2019, and 2020 to be carried back for up to five years, allowing businesses impacted by economic downturns to claim immediate tax refunds.9, 10 Following the expiration of the CARES Act provisions, the general rule has largely reverted to disallowing carrybacks for most new NOLs, emphasizing indefinite carryforwards instead.8

Key Takeaways

  • Tax loss carrybacks allow businesses and individuals to apply current net operating losses against past taxable income, potentially generating a tax refund.
  • The specific rules for tax loss carrybacks have varied significantly over time due to legislative changes, such as the TCJA and the CARES Act.
  • This tax provision helps companies manage cash flow and stabilize their financial position during periods of loss.
  • Taxpayers generally file amended returns to claim a carryback, which can result in a refund of taxes previously paid.
  • The benefit of a carryback often lies in the immediate refund it provides, which is typically more valuable than future tax savings due to the time value of money.

Interpreting the Tax Loss Carrybacks

Interpreting the impact of tax loss carrybacks involves understanding how a current year's net operating loss effectively revises the financial statements and tax liability of prior periods. When a company carries back a loss, it reduces its reported taxable income for the past year(s) to which the loss is applied. This recalculated lower income leads to a reduction in the tax previously owed, resulting in a tax refund.

For financial analysts and internal accounting principles, a successful tax loss carryback means that a portion of the tax expense recognized in prior profitable years is effectively recovered. This not only provides immediate capital but also reflects a more accurate overall tax burden for the entity across business cycles. The decision to carry back a loss versus carrying it forward (to offset future income) often hinges on the immediate need for liquidity and the comparative tax rates of past versus future years.

Hypothetical Example

Consider "Alpha Manufacturing," a company that reported the following taxable income and paid taxes at a 21% corporate tax rate:

  • Year 1: $500,000 taxable income, $105,000 tax paid
  • Year 2: $700,000 taxable income, $147,000 tax paid
  • Year 3: $600,000 taxable income, $126,000 tax paid

In Year 4, due to unforeseen market disruptions, Alpha Manufacturing experiences a significant net operating loss (NOL) of $1,200,000. Under a hypothetical tax loss carryback rule allowing a three-year carryback, Alpha can apply this NOL to its previous years.

  1. Offset Year 1: Alpha uses $500,000 of the NOL to reduce Year 1's taxable income to $0. The tax paid of $105,000 for Year 1 is now eligible for a refund.
    • Remaining NOL: $1,200,000 - $500,000 = $700,000
  2. Offset Year 2: Alpha then uses $700,000 of the remaining NOL to reduce Year 2's taxable income to $0. The tax paid of $147,000 for Year 2 is now eligible for a refund.
    • Remaining NOL: $700,000 - $700,000 = $0

In this simplified scenario, Alpha Manufacturing would be eligible for a total tax refund of $105,000 (from Year 1) + $147,000 (from Year 2) = $252,000. This immediate cash inflow can be vital for the company's survival and future investment strategy. The remaining $600,000 NOL from Year 4, if carrybacks were limited to two years in this example, would generally be carried forward to offset future taxable income.

Practical Applications

Tax loss carrybacks are a critical component of tax planning for businesses and certain individuals, particularly those with volatile revenue streams or significant startup costs.
These provisions allow companies to:

  • Improve Liquidity: By recovering taxes paid in prior profitable years, businesses can receive immediate cash refunds. This capital can be crucial for operations during a loss year, helping to cover expenses, service debt, or invest in recovery.
  • Mitigate Business Cycles: Industries prone to cyclical downturns, such as manufacturing, construction, or technology, often use carrybacks to balance their tax burden over time. A strong year's profits might be taxed heavily, but a subsequent loss year can claw back some of those taxes.
  • Encourage Investment and Risk-Taking: Knowing that losses can generate immediate tax benefits can reduce the financial risk associated with new ventures or significant capital expenditures, which might initially generate losses due to high deductions or slow revenue growth.
  • Support Economic Stability: During economic recessions, governments sometimes expand carryback provisions to inject liquidity into struggling businesses, as seen with the CARES Act during the COVID-19 pandemic. This helps prevent widespread bankruptcies and job losses. The CARES Act temporarily reversed prior restrictions on net operating loss carrybacks to provide relief to businesses impacted by the pandemic.7

Limitations and Criticisms

Despite their benefits, tax loss carrybacks have limitations and have faced criticism. One primary limitation is that their availability and duration are subject to frequent changes in tax law. As demonstrated by the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 and the subsequent CARES Act, the rules can shift, impacting a company's ability to plan.6 For example, the general elimination of carrybacks for most losses incurred after 2017 means many businesses can no longer utilize this strategy, relying solely on tax loss carryforwards.

Critics argue that carryback provisions, particularly when generous, disproportionately benefit large, established corporations with a history of profits, enabling them to reduce their overall tax burden during lean times. This can be seen as less equitable compared to smaller businesses or startups that may not have sufficient prior taxable income to utilize carrybacks effectively. Some argue that such provisions contribute to complexity in the tax code and can be seen as corporate welfare, reducing federal revenue that could otherwise fund public services.5 Additionally, while beneficial for cash flow, aggressive use of tax loss carrybacks might mask underlying financial weaknesses if a business consistently generates losses. From an economic perspective, some argue that these provisions can exacerbate income inequality by primarily benefiting wealthy shareholders.4

Tax Loss Carrybacks vs. Tax Loss Carryforwards

The key distinction between tax loss carrybacks and tax loss carryforwards lies in the direction in which a net operating loss (NOL) is applied. A tax loss carryback involves using an NOL to offset taxable income from previous tax years, often resulting in a tax refund for taxes already paid. This provides an immediate financial benefit. In contrast, a tax loss carryforward involves using an NOL to reduce taxable income in future tax years. While carryforwards do not provide an immediate refund, they reduce future tax liabilities. The choice between a carryback and a carryforward, or if a carryback is even permitted, depends on prevailing tax law and the taxpayer's specific financial situation, including past profitability and expectations for future income. Historically, carrybacks were often preferred due to the time value of money, as an immediate refund is generally more valuable than a future tax reduction.

FAQs

Q: Who can use tax loss carrybacks?

A: Historically, both individuals and corporations could utilize tax loss carrybacks, particularly when their deductions exceeded their income, creating a net operating loss. However, current U.S. tax law (post-CARES Act expiration) generally restricts carrybacks for most new losses, with some specific exceptions like certain farming losses. Individuals, estates, and trusts can find detailed guidance on NOLs in Internal Revenue Service (IRS) Publication 536.2, 3

Q: What is the primary benefit of a tax loss carryback?

A: The main benefit of a tax loss carryback is the generation of an immediate tax refund. By reducing previous years' taxable income, a taxpayer can recover taxes already paid, providing crucial cash flow during a period of financial loss.

Q: How far back can a loss typically be carried?

A: The duration for which a loss can be carried back has varied significantly throughout history and depends on specific legislative acts. Before 2018, a two-year carryback was common. The CARES Act temporarily allowed a five-year carryback for losses incurred between 2018 and 2020. Current general rules for most new losses no longer permit carrybacks, emphasizing indefinite carryforwards.1

Q: Can tax loss carrybacks offset all types of income?

A: Tax loss carrybacks primarily offset ordinary taxable income from prior years. While capital losses have their own carryback/carryforward rules against capital gains, an NOL typically results from business or trade losses, and other specific deductions. The specific types of income an NOL can offset are detailed in relevant tax law and IRS guidance.