Underwriting fee

What Is Underwriting Fee?

An underwriting fee is the compensation paid by an issuer of securities to the investment bank or syndicate of banks that facilitate a securities offering. These fees are a primary component of the costs associated with bringing new securities to the market, falling under the broader category of corporate finance within the capital markets. The underwriting fee covers the services provided by the underwriters, including advising the issuer, conducting due diligence, preparing the offering documents like the prospectus, marketing the securities to investors, and assuming the risk of purchasing and reselling the securities.²⁵ This fee represents the largest direct cost for companies undertaking an initial public offering (IPO) or other public offering.²⁴

History and Origin

The concept of an underwriting fee evolved alongside the development of organized securities markets and the increasing complexity of capital raises. In the early days of finance, offerings were often direct, or facilitated by brokers who simply connected buyers and sellers. However, as the demand for larger, more structured capital raises grew, particularly with the rise of industrialization, the role of financial intermediaries expanded. Investment banks began to emerge as entities that not only advised on these transactions but also committed to purchasing the entire issuance, thereby guaranteeing the proceeds for the issuer. This assumption of risk, known as underwriting, necessitated a form of compensation.

Significant regulatory changes in the early 20th century, particularly in the United States, further shaped the modern underwriting process and its associated fees. The Securities Act of 1933 and the Glass-Steagall Act of 1933 (part of the larger Banking Act of 1933) introduced reforms aimed at investor protection and separating commercial banking from investment banking.,²³ These acts mandated greater disclosure for public offerings and formalized the responsibilities of underwriters, solidifying their role and the fees they charged for their services.²² The "spread" or discount at which underwriters purchased shares from the issuer, and subsequently sold them to the public, became the established form of the underwriting fee. The standard underwriting discount for moderate-sized IPOs has remained around 7% for decades, a figure that has been a subject of discussion within the industry.²¹

Key Takeaways

An underwriting fee is the compensation paid to investment banks for facilitating securities offerings.
It covers advisory services, due diligence, marketing, and risk assumption by the underwriters.
Underwriting fees are typically calculated as a percentage of the gross proceeds from the offering.
These fees are often the largest direct cost for companies undertaking an IPO or other public issuance.
Factors such as offering size, market conditions, and issuer reputation can influence the fee percentage.

Formula and Calculation

The underwriting fee is generally calculated as a percentage of the total gross proceeds of the securities offering. This percentage, known as the "underwriting discount" or "gross spread," is the difference between the price at which the underwriters buy the securities from the issuer and the price at which they sell them to the public.

The formula can be expressed as:

\text{Underwriting Fee} = \text{Offering Price per Share} \times \text{Number of Shares Offered} \times \text{Underwriting Fee Percentage}

Alternatively, if considering the gross proceeds:

\text{Underwriting Fee} = \text{Gross Proceeds} \times \text{Underwriting Fee Percentage}

Where:

Gross Proceeds = Total funds raised by the issuer before deducting fees.
Offering Price per Share = The price at which each share is offered to the public.
Number of Shares Offered = The total quantity of financial instrument being sold.
Underwriting Fee Percentage = The agreed-upon percentage of the gross proceeds that the underwriter receives as compensation. This percentage can vary but often falls within a common range for different types of offerings.²⁰

Interpreting the Underwriting Fee

Interpreting the underwriting fee involves understanding its significance as both a cost to the issuer and compensation for the underwriter's services and risk. For the issuing entity, the underwriting fee represents a substantial expense, directly reducing the net proceeds received from the equity offering or debt offering. Companies consider this cost when deciding whether to raise capital through a public offering versus other methods like a private placement.¹⁹

From the perspective of the underwriting syndicate, the fee compensates them for a complex array of activities:

Advisory Services: Guiding the issuer through the intricate process of going public or issuing debt.
Due Diligence: Thoroughly investigating the issuer to ensure accuracy and completeness of regulatory filings.
Marketing and Distribution: Leveraging their network to market and sell the securities to a wide base of investors.
Risk Assumption: Committing to purchase the securities, thus taking on the market risk if they cannot be sold to the public at the offering price.

The size of the underwriting fee percentage can be influenced by several factors: the issuer's size and reputation, the market's current volatility, the complexity of the offering, and the competitive landscape among investment banks. Larger, more established companies with strong financials often negotiate lower percentages than smaller, less known entities due to lower perceived risk and higher demand for their securities.

Hypothetical Example

Imagine "TechWave Innovations," a fast-growing software company, decides to go public through an initial public offering (IPO) to raise capital for expansion. TechWave hires "Global Capital Markets," an investment bank, to underwrite the offering.

Offering Details: TechWave decides to issue 10 million shares to the public.
Offering Price: After discussions and market analysis, Global Capital Markets recommends an offering price of $20 per share.
Gross Proceeds: The total value of the offering would be 10 million shares * $20/share = $200 million.
Underwriting Fee Percentage: Global Capital Markets and TechWave agree on an underwriting fee of 5% of the gross proceeds, a common percentage for an IPO of this size.

Calculation of Underwriting Fee:

Underwriting Fee = Gross Proceeds × Underwriting Fee Percentage
Underwriting Fee = $200,000,000 × 0.05
Underwriting Fee = $10,000,000

In this hypothetical example, TechWave Innovations would pay Global Capital Markets an underwriting fee of $10 million. Consequently, out of the $200 million raised from the public, TechWave would net $190 million after deducting the underwriting fee. This fee covers Global Capital Markets' services in bringing TechWave's shares to market, including all the preparatory work, marketing, and the financial risk taken on by the bank.

Practical Applications

Underwriting fees are a pervasive element in various segments of the capital markets and are particularly prominent in transactions involving new securities issuances.

Initial Public Offerings (IPOs): As discussed, underwriting fees are the primary cost for companies transitioning from private to public ownership. The fees compensate investment banks for their extensive work in valuing the company, preparing regulatory documents, and distributing shares to investors. F¹⁸or many IPOs, the underwriting discount can range from 4% to 7% of the gross proceeds, although larger deals might see lower percentages.,
¹⁷2¹⁶. Follow-on Public Offerings: When publicly traded companies issue additional shares after their IPO, they also engage underwriters. These equity offering fees tend to be lower than IPO fees because the company is already public and has established reporting.
Bond Issuance and Debt Offerings: Governments and corporations frequently issue bonds to raise capital. Underwriting fees for debt instruments are generally lower than for equity, reflecting the different risk profiles and distribution efforts involved.
Rights Offerings: Existing shareholders are given the right to purchase new shares, often at a discount. Underwriters may still be involved to ensure the full subscription of the offering and will charge a fee for this commitment.
Regulatory Disclosure: Companies are required to disclose these fees in their regulatory filings with bodies like the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), providing transparency on the costs of capital raising. The SEC has modernized its filing fee disclosure requirements to enhance transparency and efficiency.

¹⁵Recent trends in the market show that while global investment banking fees have seen overall increases in strong market years, u¹⁴nderwriting fees can still fluctuate significantly based on market conditions, such as downturns impacting overall IPO volumes.,
¹³
¹²## Limitations and Criticisms

While underwriting fees are a standard component of securities offerings, they are not without limitations and criticisms. One common critique revolves around the perception that these fees are excessively high, particularly the relatively static 7% fee for many mid-sized IPOs, leading some to label it an "IPO tax." C¹¹ritics argue that in an increasingly technological and competitive environment, such a fixed percentage seems disproportionate to the actual costs incurred by investment banks, especially for smaller deals.,
¹⁰
⁹Another point of contention is the potential for conflicts of interest. Underwriters aim to maximize their fees, which are often a percentage of the deal size, incentivizing them to get a deal done, potentially at a valuation that might not be optimal for the issuer. T⁸here's also a potential conflict if the underwriter also provides other advisory services, where the bank might prioritize a swift transaction over achieving the highest possible proceeds for the issuer.

⁷Furthermore, the "underpricing" phenomenon in IPOs—where the initial offering price is set below what the market ultimately values the stock at shortly after trading begins—is sometimes viewed as a hidden underwriting fee. This ⁶practice results in immediate gains for investors who receive shares at the offering price, but it means the issuing company leaves money on the table that could have been raised, effectively transferring value from the issuer to the investors and the underwriters. This "money left on the table" can far exceed the direct underwriting fees paid.

Issuers typically lack the expertise and market access to conduct a public offering independently, making them reliant on underwriters. This dependency can limit their bargaining power over fees. While fees are negotiable, smaller or less reputable issuers may find less flexibility.

U⁵nderwriting Fee vs. Selling Concession

While both the underwriting fee and the selling concession are components of the compensation structure in a securities offering, they represent distinct parts of the total gross spread.

The underwriting fee (or underwriting discount/gross spread) is the overall compensation paid by the issuer to the entire syndicate of underwriters for their services, including market research, pricing, risk bearing, and distribution. It is the difference between what the issuer receives for its securities and the public offering price.

The selling concession, on the other hand, is the portion of the underwriting fee specifically allocated to the syndicate members (which can include the lead underwriter as well as other brokers) for successfully selling the securities to investors. It compensates the sales force for their efforts in finding buyers and distributing the shares. Think of it as a commission paid per share sold.

In a typical syndicate structure, the total gross spread (the underwriting fee) is divided into three parts: a management fee (for the lead underwriter's overall coordination), an underwriting fee (for the risk assumed by the syndicate members), and the selling concession. The selling concession often constitutes the largest portion of the total gross spread, typically around 60%.

Esse⁴ntially, the underwriting fee is the total pie of compensation, while the selling concession is a slice of that pie specifically for sales efforts.

FAQs

How are underwriting fees determined?

Underwriting fees are determined through negotiations between the issuer and the lead investment bank. Factors influencing the fee include the type and size of the offering, the issuer's financial health and market reputation, prevailing market conditions, and the perceived risk of the offering. Generally, larger and less risky offerings tend to have lower percentage fees.

Are underwriting fees negotiable?

Yes, underwriting fees are generally negotiable. Issuers with strong market demand for their securities or those undertaking very large offerings may have more leverage to negotiate a lower fee percentage.

³Who pays the underwriting fee?

The company or entity issuing the securities pays the underwriting fee. This fee is typically deducted directly from the gross proceeds of the offering, meaning the issuer receives the net amount after the fee has been subtracted.

Do underwriting fees apply to all types of financial products?

Underwriting fees are most commonly associated with primary market offerings of stocks and bonds. While the term "underwriting" also applies in insurance, the fee structure differs, often being integrated into the premium rather than a separate explicit fee. In so²me lending contexts, such as mortgages, there might be a small underwriting fee covering the administrative costs of evaluating a loan application.¹