Yield to call

What Is Yield to Call?

Yield to call (YTC) is the total return an investor would receive if they held a callable bond until its call date, assuming the bond is called by the issuer. This metric is a crucial component of fixed-income securities analysis, particularly for investors evaluating debt instruments with embedded call provisions. It reflects the potential return on a bond investment when an issuer exercises its right to repurchase the bond before its scheduled maturity date, typically when prevailing interest rates decline.

History and Origin

The concept of callable bonds, and by extension, yield to call, emerged as a mechanism to provide flexibility for bond issuers. Companies and governments issue bonds to raise capital, and call provisions allow them to refinance debt at lower interest rates if market conditions become more favorable. This is analogous to a homeowner refinancing a mortgage. The ability to call bonds was a significant development, offering issuers a way to manage their debt obligations dynamically. Historically, U.S. Treasury bonds, for instance, have included callable features, with 30-year area bonds becoming a regular feature callable after 25 years in 1977, a practice that evolved over time.⁵ The widespread adoption of call features in corporate and municipal bonds made it necessary for investors to consider the possibility of early redemption, thus giving rise to the need for a calculation like yield to call to assess the true potential return.

Key Takeaways

Yield to call (YTC) represents the anticipated return on a bond if it is redeemed by the issuer on its earliest or next call date.
YTC is particularly relevant for callable bonds, which give the issuer the right to repurchase the bond before maturity.
It is often calculated when a bond is trading at a premium bond, indicating that market interest rates are below the bond's coupon rate.
For investors, understanding YTC helps assess reinvestment risk should the bond be called early.

Formula and Calculation

The calculation of yield to call is similar to the yield to maturity (YTM) calculation but uses the call price and the time until the call date instead of the par value and time to maturity. Since it's typically iterative, like YTM, it doesn't have a simple direct algebraic solution. However, it can be approximated or solved numerically.

The basic present value formula for a bond is:

P = \sum_{t=1}^{N} \frac{C}{(1+YTC)^t} + \frac{CP}{(1+YTC)^N}

Where:

(P) = Market price of the bond
(C) = Annual coupon payment (Coupon rate × Face Value)
(N) = Number of periods until the bond's call date
(CP) = Call price of the bond
(YTC) = Yield to call (the variable to solve for)

This formula requires an iterative method (such as trial and error or financial calculator/software) to solve for YTC, as it cannot be rearranged algebraically.

Interpreting the Yield to Call

Yield to call is an essential metric for investors to understand the potential return on a callable bond. When current interest rates fall significantly below a bond's coupon rate, the issuer has a strong incentive to exercise its call option to refinance debt at a lower cost. In such scenarios, the yield to call becomes the more relevant measure of an investor's expected return than the bond's yield to maturity, as the bond is likely to be called. Conversely, if interest rates rise, the bond is less likely to be called, and the yield to maturity would be a more appropriate measure. ⁴Investors often compare a bond's yield to call with other available bond yields in the market to make informed investment decisions.

Hypothetical Example

Consider an investor who buys a callable bond with the following characteristics:

Face Value: $1,000
Coupon Rate: 5% (paid semi-annually, so $25 every six months)
Current Market Price: $1,050
Call Price: $1,020 (plus accrued interest)
Call Date: 2 years from now (4 semi-annual periods)

To calculate the yield to call, the investor would determine the discount rate (YTC) that equates the present value of the future coupon payments and the call price to the current market price of $1,050.

Using an iterative process (e.g., a financial calculator or spreadsheet function):

Input:
- Present Value (PV) = -$1,050 (cash outflow)
- Future Value (FV) = $1,020 (call price)
- Payment (PMT) = $25 (semi-annual coupon)
- Number of Periods (N) = 4 (semi-annual periods to call date)
Solve for Interest Rate (I/Y): The semi-annual yield to call would be approximately 1.76%.
Annualize: Multiply the semi-annual YTC by 2: 1.76% * 2 = 3.52%.

In this scenario, the yield to call is 3.52%. This indicates that if the bond is called in two years, the investor's annualized return would be approximately 3.52%, which is significantly lower than the 5% coupon rate due to purchasing the bond at a premium and receiving a call price that is lower than the premium paid. This example illustrates why financial analysis of callable bonds must consider the yield to call.

Practical Applications

Yield to call is a practical tool used extensively in the bond market by investors, analysts, and portfolio managers.

Investment Decisions: Investors utilize YTC to assess the worst-case scenario return for a premium bond. If a bond is trading above its par value, it's highly susceptible to being called when interest rates fall. Understanding the yield to call helps investors manage their expectations for returns and avoid unpleasant surprises.
³* Risk Management: For portfolio managers, YTC helps quantify reinvestment risk. If a significant portion of a portfolio consists of callable bonds with high YTCs (relative to YTM) in a falling interest rate environment, those bonds are likely to be called, forcing the manager to reinvest at potentially lower rates.
Bond Valuation: While complex, the valuation of callable bonds fundamentally involves subtracting the value of the embedded call option from the value of an otherwise identical non-callable bond. This is often done using advanced mathematical models, such as those employing partial differential equations, which implicitly incorporate the concept of a yield to call or a similar early redemption yield in their calculations.
²* Disclosure and Regulation: Regulatory bodies like the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) emphasize transparency in bond offerings. Issuers of callable bonds must clearly disclose their call provisions, allowing investors to understand potential call dates and prices.
¹

Limitations and Criticisms

While yield to call is a valuable metric, it has limitations.

Assumption of Call: The primary criticism is that YTC assumes the bond will be called on its first or next call date. This is not guaranteed, as the issuer's decision depends on future interest rates and their specific financing needs, which may or may not align with market expectations.
Single Call Date Focus: A bond might have multiple call dates and prices. YTC typically focuses on the earliest or next call date that would result in the lowest possible yield, a concept sometimes referred to as "yield to worst." However, if a bond is called on a later date at a different price, the actual return will differ from the initially calculated yield to call.
Ignores Other Risks: YTC does not factor in other critical risks like default risk, liquidity risk, or inflation risk. Investors must consider these factors in conjunction with yield to call for a comprehensive bond analysis.

Yield to Call vs. Yield to Maturity

Yield to call (Yield to call) and yield to maturity (YTM) are both measures of bond yields, but they apply to different scenarios, particularly for callable bonds. Yield to maturity represents the total return an investor expects to receive if they hold a bond until its scheduled maturity date, assuming all coupon payments are made and reinvested at the same rate. This calculation does not account for any early redemption options.

In contrast, yield to call specifically calculates the return if a callable bond is redeemed by the issuer on a specified call date before maturity. For a premium bond (one trading above its par value), the yield to call will generally be lower than the yield to maturity because the investor receives the principal back earlier and at a lower call price than the price paid for the bond. The key distinction lies in the assumption of the bond's life: YTM assumes holding until maturity, while YTC assumes early redemption at the issuer's discretion.

FAQs

When is yield to call most relevant?

Yield to call is most relevant when a callable bond is trading at a premium, meaning its market price is higher than its par value and its call price. This usually occurs when prevailing interest rates have fallen significantly below the bond's coupon rate, making it financially attractive for the issuer to call the bond and refinance at a lower rate.

Does yield to call account for all risks?

No, yield to call primarily addresses the risk of early redemption and its impact on an investor's return. It does not account for other risks such as default risk, inflation risk, or liquidity risk. A comprehensive financial analysis requires considering all relevant risks.

Is a higher yield to call always better for an investor?

Not necessarily. A higher yield to call might indicate a higher potential return if the bond is called. However, if the bond is not called, the investor's actual return might be closer to the yield to maturity. The "better" yield depends on the investor's expectations about future interest rates and the likelihood of the bond being called.