Acquired excess reserves

What Is Acquired Excess Reserves?

Acquired excess reserves refer to the cash balances that commercial banks hold at their central bank that exceed the legally mandated reserve requirements. These reserves are primarily a result of large-scale asset purchase programs conducted by central banks, falling under the broader category of Central Banking and Monetary Policy. Historically, banks held minimal excess reserves due to the opportunity cost of foregone interest from lending. However, following significant financial events, central bank actions have led to a dramatic increase in these balances. These acquired excess reserves represent a substantial portion of the banking system's liquidity, influencing how monetary policy is transmitted and impacting the financial landscape.

History and Origin

The concept of banks holding reserves above a stipulated minimum has long existed, but the widespread accumulation of acquired excess reserves is a relatively recent phenomenon, largely stemming from the 2007–2008 Financial Crisis and subsequent central bank interventions. Prior to this period, banks typically maintained only a small amount of excess reserves, primarily for operational purposes, as reserves held at the central bank did not earn interest, making them an unattractive holding compared to interest-earning assets.
¹³, ¹⁴
However, the onset of the financial crisis prompted central banks, such as the U.S. Federal Reserve, to take extraordinary measures to stabilize financial markets and stimulate the economy. These measures included significantly expanding their balance sheet through various lending facilities and large-scale asset purchases, commonly known as Quantitative Easing (QE). ¹²For instance, in response to the crisis, the Federal Reserve's total reserves in the banking system expanded dramatically, with excess reserves growing from approximately $1.9 billion in August 2008 to $2.6 trillion by January 2015. ¹¹This unprecedented increase in reserves was largely a consequence of the Fed purchasing vast quantities of government bonds and mortgage-backed securities from commercial banks, which then saw their reserve accounts at the Federal Reserve credited with the corresponding amounts. A critical policy change in October 2008, which allowed the Federal Reserve to pay interest on reserves, further incentivized banks to hold these acquired excess reserves, rather than lending them out, thereby creating a floor for market interest rates.
⁹, ¹⁰

Key Takeaways

• Acquired excess reserves are bank balances held at a central bank beyond regulatory requirements, primarily amassed due to central bank asset purchases.
• The significant increase in acquired excess reserves began after the 2008 financial crisis, driven by quantitative easing programs.
• Central banks' ability to pay interest on reserves fundamentally changed banks' incentives to hold large quantities of these reserves.
• High levels of acquired excess reserves can alter the mechanisms through which central banks implement monetary policy.
• These reserves play a crucial role in the financial system's overall liquidity and stability.

Interpreting Acquired Excess Reserves

The level of acquired excess reserves provides insight into the liquidity conditions within the banking system and the stance of a central bank's monetary policy. A substantial volume of acquired excess reserves indicates an abundant reserve environment, a departure from the historical "scarce reserves" regime. In such an environment, banks have ample funds deposited at the central bank, reducing their need to borrow from one another in the federal funds market for short-term liquidity needs.

This abundance allows the central bank to influence short-term interest rates primarily by adjusting the interest rate it pays on these reserves, rather than through traditional open market operations that directly alter the supply of reserves. ⁷, ⁸Interpreting large holdings of acquired excess reserves requires understanding that banks are willing to hold these balances because they now earn interest, making them a safe and liquid asset. The sheer volume of these reserves reflects the central bank's expansive policies aimed at stimulating the economy and ensuring financial stability.

Hypothetical Example

Imagine a scenario where the economy is facing a severe downturn, and the central bank decides to implement a large-scale asset purchase program to inject liquidity into the financial system. Let's say "Diversified Bank" has $100 million in government bonds on its balance sheet.

1. Central Bank Action: The central bank announces it will purchase $50 billion in government bonds from commercial banks.
2. Diversified Bank's Participation: Diversified Bank sells $10 million of its government bonds to the central bank.
3. Reserve Increase: In exchange for the bonds, the central bank credits Diversified Bank's account at the central bank by $10 million.
4. Reserve Requirements Check: If Diversified Bank's required reserves based on its deposits are, for example, $2 million, the additional $10 million received from the central bank effectively increases its acquired excess reserves by that amount. Its total bank reserves are now higher than before the transaction.
5. Result: Diversified Bank now holds an additional $10 million in highly liquid, interest-earning reserves beyond what is required, which are considered acquired excess reserves. This increase provides the bank with greater capacity for lending or investment, contributing to overall systemic liquidity.

Practical Applications

Acquired excess reserves have practical implications across several facets of finance and the broader economy, particularly in the realm of monetary policy and banking operations.

Central banks leverage the payment of interest on acquired excess reserves as a key tool to manage short-term interest rates. By adjusting the interest rate paid on these reserves, a central bank can influence banks' willingness to lend or hold onto funds, even when reserves are abundant. ⁶This mechanism helps guide the overall cost of borrowing in the economy.

Furthermore, these large reserve holdings enhance the banking system's liquidity. In times of financial stress, abundant reserves can act as a buffer, making banks more resilient to sudden withdrawals or market disruptions, thus contributing to greater financial stability. This was a significant consideration following the 2008 financial crisis, where the substantial increase in acquired excess reserves helped to shore up the banking sector.
⁵
For commercial banks, acquired excess reserves represent a low-risk, albeit potentially lower-yield, asset. While banks traditionally sought to minimize excess reserves to maximize lending profits, the payment of interest by the central bank on these balances transformed them into an attractive, safe investment, influencing banks' asset allocation decisions. The Federal Reserve's H.4.1 statistical release provides regular updates on the factors affecting reserve balances, including excess reserves, offering transparency into these key monetary aggregates.
⁴

Limitations and Criticisms

Despite their role in stabilizing financial systems and influencing monetary policy, acquired excess reserves are not without limitations and criticisms. One concern revolves around their potential impact on money supply and inflation. While large excess reserves in themselves do not automatically lead to inflation, the sheer volume represents a latent capacity for increased lending and money creation. Policymakers must remain vigilant to prevent a sudden and rapid expansion of credit if banks decide to significantly draw down these reserves for lending, which could ignite inflationary pressures.
², ³
Another criticism pertains to the efficiency of monetary policy transmission in an abundant reserve environment. Some argue that when banks hold vast amounts of acquired excess reserves, the traditional links between central bank actions and real economic activity might become less direct or predictable. The central bank's influence on lending behavior may be blunted if banks opt to hold reserves rather than increase lending, even with a favorable interest rate on reserves. While the payment of interest on reserves allows the central bank to manage market rates, there are arguments about the potential for policy to "get behind the curve" if the scale of excess reserves leads to unforeseen market dynamics. ¹Moreover, the very act of maintaining such a large central bank balance sheet through significant asset purchases has drawn debate regarding its long-term implications for market functioning and the central bank's independence.

Acquired Excess Reserves vs. Required Reserves

The distinction between acquired excess reserves and required reserves is fundamental to understanding bank liquidity and monetary policy.

The confusion often arises because both are types of bank reserves held at the central bank. However, their policy implications and the reasons for their existence in large quantities differ significantly. Required reserves are a regulatory mandate, while acquired excess reserves, particularly in the post-2008 era, are a consequence of deliberate monetary policy aimed at injecting substantial liquidity into the financial system.

FAQs

What caused the significant increase in acquired excess reserves?

The dramatic rise in acquired excess reserves was primarily caused by central bank responses to the 2007–2008 Financial Crisis, especially through programs like Quantitative Easing. These programs involved the central bank purchasing large quantities of assets from commercial banks, crediting their reserve accounts and thus increasing their balances held at the central bank beyond what was legally required.

Do acquired excess reserves cause inflation?

While large amounts of acquired excess reserves represent a potential for increased bank lending, they do not automatically lead to inflation. Central banks can manage this risk by paying interest on reserves, which gives banks an incentive to hold onto these funds rather than immediately lending them out, thereby influencing the overall money supply.

How do acquired excess reserves impact monetary policy?

Acquired excess reserves have fundamentally changed how central banks conduct monetary policy. In an environment of abundant reserves, the central bank can influence short-term interest rates primarily by adjusting the interest rate it pays on these reserves, rather than by directly altering the quantity of reserves through open market operations. This is often referred to as a "floor system" for implementing policy.