Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to A Definitions

Adjusted bid ask spread

Adjusted Bid-Ask Spread

The adjusted bid-ask spread is a refined measure of the true cost of trading a security, particularly in fragmented or rapidly moving markets, falling under the broader field of Market Microstructure. It seeks to capture the actual transaction cost incurred by an investor, moving beyond the simple quoted difference between the highest bid and lowest ask prices at a given moment. This metric is crucial because the quoted Bid-Ask Spread may not always reflect the price at which an order is ultimately executed, especially with phenomena like price improvement or adverse selection. Understanding the adjusted bid-ask spread provides a more accurate assessment of Liquidity and the real Transaction Costs associated with trading.

History and Origin

The concept of measuring and dissecting the costs of trading, including the bid-ask spread, has been central to financial economics for decades. Early models, such as those by Richard Roll in 1984, began to implicitly measure the effective spread from observed transaction prices. However, as financial markets evolved with increasing automation and speed, particularly with the advent of High-Frequency Trading and Algorithmic Trading, the need for more nuanced measures became apparent.

The development of the adjusted bid-ask spread gained prominence as market participants and regulators sought better ways to assess Execution Quality across various trading venues. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) introduced rules, such as Rule 605 of Regulation NMS, which mandates market centers to disclose information about their order executions, including effective spreads6. This regulatory push encouraged the development of more precise calculations that account for factors beyond the simple stated quotes, recognizing that the actual cost paid by investors could differ significantly. Landmark academic work, such as "Asset Prices and the Bid-Ask Spread" by Yakov Amihud and Haim Mendelson in 1986, laid theoretical foundations for understanding how trading costs impact asset valuation, contributing to the analytical framework for such adjusted measures5. The dramatic volatility seen during events like the 2010 "Flash Crash," where prices moved rapidly, further underscored the limitations of static bid-ask spread measures and the importance of dynamic, adjusted calculations to reflect true market conditions4.

Key Takeaways

  • The adjusted bid-ask spread provides a more accurate reflection of the actual cost of executing a trade than the quoted bid-ask spread.
  • It accounts for factors such as price improvement or adverse selection, which can cause the executed price to differ from the prevailing quote.
  • This metric is vital for assessing market liquidity, comparing execution quality across different market centers, and evaluating overall trading efficiency.
  • A lower adjusted bid-ask spread generally indicates higher liquidity and lower transaction costs for investors.
  • It is a key analytical tool for sophisticated traders, institutional investors, and researchers in market microstructure.

Formula and Calculation

The adjusted bid-ask spread is often approximated by what is commonly referred to as the "effective spread." While there can be variations depending on the specific model or data available, a common approach to calculating the effective spread for a trade is:

Effective Spread=2×∣Transaction Price−Midpoint of the Quote∣\text{Effective Spread} = 2 \times | \text{Transaction Price} - \text{Midpoint of the Quote} |

Where:

  • Transaction Price refers to the price at which the trade actually occurred.
  • Midpoint of the Quote is the average of the National Best Bid and Offer (NBBO) at the time the order was received. This is calculated as: Midpoint of the Quote=Best Ask+Best Bid2\text{Midpoint of the Quote} = \frac{\text{Best Ask} + \text{Best Bid}}{2} Here, "Best Ask" is the lowest price a seller is willing to accept, and "Best Bid" is the highest price a buyer is willing to pay from the Order Book.

For a buy order, if the transaction occurs below the midpoint, it implies price improvement; conversely, for a sell order, a transaction above the midpoint indicates price improvement. The absolute difference captures the deviation from the midpoint, and multiplying by two annualizes the spread across the entire transaction.

Interpreting the Adjusted Bid-Ask Spread

The adjusted bid-ask spread offers a more nuanced interpretation of trading costs compared to the simple quoted spread. A smaller adjusted bid-ask spread indicates better Price Discovery and lower effective Transaction Costs for investors. For example, if an investor places a Market Order to buy a stock, and the order is executed at a price better than the prevailing ask price, the adjusted spread will reflect this price improvement. Conversely, in volatile markets, or for illiquid securities, the actual execution price might be worse than the prevailing quote, leading to a larger adjusted spread that captures the true cost of immediate execution.

This metric is particularly insightful for evaluating the efficiency of different trading venues and the performance of Market Makers. A consistently large adjusted bid-ask spread for a frequently traded security might signal underlying issues with market liquidity or structure.

Hypothetical Example

Consider XYZ stock. At 10:00 AM, its National Best Bid and Offer (NBBO) is:

  • Best Bid: $49.90
  • Best Ask: $50.10

The midpoint of the quote at this time is ( ($49.90 + $50.10) / 2 = $50.00 ).

Scenario 1: Price Improvement
An investor places a market order to buy 100 shares of XYZ. Due to the efficiency of the trading system and available liquidity, the order is executed at $50.05 per share.
The quoted bid-ask spread was ( $50.10 - $49.90 = $0.20 ).
The adjusted bid-ask spread for this buy order would be:

Adjusted Bid-Ask Spread=2×∣$50.05−$50.00∣=2×$0.05=$0.10\text{Adjusted Bid-Ask Spread} = 2 \times | \$50.05 - \$50.00 | = 2 \times \$0.05 = \$0.10

In this case, the adjusted spread ($0.10) is half of the quoted spread ($0.20), indicating a favorable execution due to price improvement. The investor effectively paid less than the quoted ask price.

Scenario 2: Adverse Selection
An investor places a market order to sell 100 shares of XYZ. Immediately after the order is placed but before execution, significant selling pressure causes the market to drop, and the order is executed at $49.85. The original midpoint was still $50.00.
The adjusted bid-ask spread for this sell order would be:

Adjusted Bid-Ask Spread=2×∣$49.85−$50.00∣=2×∣−$0.15∣=$0.30\text{Adjusted Bid-Ask Spread} = 2 \times | \$49.85 - \$50.00 | = 2 \times | -\$0.15 | = \$0.30

Here, the adjusted spread ($0.30) is larger than the original quoted spread ($0.20), reflecting the adverse price movement that occurred during the execution. The investor effectively received less than the quoted bid price. This highlights how the adjusted bid-ask spread captures the real cost in dynamic market conditions.

Practical Applications

The adjusted bid-ask spread is widely used in various facets of financial markets:

  • Broker Performance Evaluation: Institutional investors and individual traders can use the adjusted bid-ask spread to compare the Execution Quality provided by different brokers or market centers. Brokers that consistently achieve smaller adjusted spreads for their clients demonstrate superior execution capabilities.
  • Algorithmic Trading Strategies: High-frequency trading firms and other quantitative traders incorporate the adjusted bid-ask spread into their algorithms to optimize trade timing and minimize transaction costs, which are critical for their profitability.
  • Market Research and Analysis: Academics and financial analysts use the adjusted bid-ask spread to study market liquidity, Market Efficiency, and the impact of market structure changes. For instance, research has shown how measures like the effective spread can be used to estimate true trading costs, providing a more reliable gauge than simple quoted spreads3.
  • Regulatory Oversight: Regulators, such as the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), utilize data on adjusted spreads (often referred to as effective spreads in their disclosures) to monitor market fairness and identify potential issues with market centers' practices. Recent amendments to SEC Rule 605 have expanded the scope of entities and order types required to report execution quality metrics, including those related to effective spreads, to enhance transparency2.

Limitations and Criticisms

While the adjusted bid-ask spread offers a more accurate picture of trading costs, it is not without limitations:

  • Data Availability and Granularity: Calculating the adjusted bid-ask spread accurately requires highly granular trade and quote data, often millisecond-level timestamps and the exact National Best Bid and Offer (NBBO) at the moment an order is received. Such data can be expensive and complex to process for individual investors or smaller firms.
  • Complexity of Orders: The calculation presented is simplified for market orders. For more complex order types, such as Limit Orders or stop orders, the interpretation and calculation of effective costs can become significantly more intricate.
  • Market Conditions: In extremely volatile or illiquid markets, the adjusted bid-ask spread can fluctuate wildly, making it challenging to derive stable or representative measures. Rapid price changes between order submission and execution can lead to large, potentially misleading, adjusted spread figures.
  • Bias in Measurement: Academic research has noted that the effective bid-ask spread, when measured relative to the spread midpoint, can overstate the true effective bid-ask spread, particularly in markets with discrete prices and elastic liquidity demand. This bias can vary across stocks and trading venues, potentially leading to suboptimal decisions in stock selection or order routing1.

Adjusted Bid-Ask Spread vs. Effective Bid-Ask Spread

The terms adjusted bid-ask spread and effective bid-ask spread are often used interchangeably to describe a measure of transaction costs that accounts for the actual execution price relative to the prevailing midpoint. Both aim to go beyond the nominal Bid-Ask Spread to reflect the true cost paid by an investor.

The confusion arises largely because "effective bid-ask spread" is the more commonly formalized term used in academic literature and regulatory disclosures (e.g., SEC Rule 605 reports). "Adjusted" often serves as a more descriptive, plain-language synonym implying that the raw spread has been refined or corrected for factors like price improvement. Therefore, when discussing the actual cost of a trade that considers how far the execution price deviates from the midpoint of the quoted market, both terms refer to the same underlying concept: a more accurate reflection of Transaction Costs than the simple quoted spread.

FAQs

What does a high adjusted bid-ask spread indicate?
A high adjusted bid-ask spread typically indicates lower Liquidity for the security or adverse market conditions during the trade. It means the actual cost incurred by the investor to execute the trade was higher, possibly due to a lack of willing buyers or sellers, or significant price movements between order placement and execution.

Why is the adjusted bid-ask spread important for investors?
It is important because it provides a realistic measure of trading costs. For active traders or large institutional investors, even small differences in the adjusted bid-ask spread can significantly impact profitability or portfolio performance over many trades. It helps them assess how well their orders are being executed.

How does the adjusted bid-ask spread relate to market efficiency?
In highly efficient markets, where Price Discovery is rapid and information is quickly incorporated into prices, the adjusted bid-ask spread tends to be narrower. This reflects minimal price impact from trades and lower implicit transaction costs, contributing to overall Market Efficiency.

Can an investor experience a negative adjusted bid-ask spread?
No, the adjusted bid-ask spread is typically expressed as an absolute value or a non-negative number, representing a cost. While price improvement can significantly reduce the adjusted spread compared to the quoted spread, it will still represent a cost relative to the midpoint of the best bid and offer, or at best, zero if the trade occurs precisely at the midpoint.

Is the adjusted bid-ask spread relevant for long-term investors?
While more critical for frequent traders, the adjusted bid-ask spread is still relevant for long-term investors as it contributes to the total Transaction Costs they incur when entering or exiting positions. Understanding this cost helps in evaluating the overall return on investment, especially for less liquid securities or larger trade sizes.