Skip to main content
← Back to E Definitions

Earnings effect

What Is Earnings Effect?

The earnings effect refers to the observed phenomenon where a company's stock price tends to react to the announcement of its financial results, often beyond the immediate reporting period. This concept falls under the broader financial category of capital markets and investment analysis. It suggests that the information contained within an earnings report is not always fully and instantaneously incorporated into the stock price, leading to a persistent directional movement. The earnings effect is particularly notable when reported earnings deviate significantly from market expectations, leading to what is known as an earnings surprise.

History and Origin

The study of how earnings announcements impact stock prices has a long history in financial research. One of the earliest and most influential studies documenting this phenomenon was conducted by Ray Ball and Philip Brown in 1968. Their seminal work observed that stock prices tend to drift in the direction of an earnings surprise for an extended period after the initial announcement, a finding that challenged the prevailing notion of efficient markets which posited immediate and full price adjustment to new information42, 43, 44, 45. This observed delayed reaction, specifically known as the "post-earnings announcement drift" (PEAD), became a significant area of research in financial economics and behavioral finance. The initial finding by Ball and Brown (1968) indicated that positive earnings news was followed by upward price movements, while negative news led to downward drifts, sometimes lasting for months41.

Key Takeaways

  • The earnings effect describes the tendency for stock prices to continue moving in the direction of an earnings surprise (positive or negative) for a period after the earnings announcement.
  • It challenges the strong form of the efficient market hypothesis by suggesting that new information is not always immediately and fully reflected in stock prices.39, 40
  • Explanations for the earnings effect often involve concepts like delayed information processing, investor sentiment, and limits to arbitrage.
  • Understanding the earnings effect can be relevant for developing trading strategies and for assessing the full impact of a company's financial reporting.

Formula and Calculation

The earnings effect itself is an observed market phenomenon rather than a single calculated metric. However, researchers often quantify the impact of earnings surprises and the subsequent drift using measures related to unexpected earnings and abnormal returns.

A common way to measure the "surprise" element is through Standardized Unexpected Earnings (SUE):

SUE=Actual EPSExpected EPSStandard Deviation of Expected EPSSUE = \frac{Actual~EPS - Expected~EPS}{Standard~Deviation~of~Expected~EPS}

Where:

  • Actual EPSActual~EPS = The company's reported earnings per share.
  • Expected EPSExpected~EPS = The consensus analyst forecasts for EPS.
  • Standard Deviation of Expected EPSStandard~Deviation~of~Expected~EPS = A measure of the dispersion or variability of the analyst forecasts, used to standardize the surprise across different companies.

The subsequent earnings effect is then observed by analyzing the cumulative abnormal returns (CAR) of a stock or portfolio following the earnings announcement.

Interpreting the Earnings Effect

Interpreting the earnings effect involves understanding that even after a company releases its quarterly or annual earnings, the market's reaction may not be instantaneous or complete. A significant positive earnings surprise, for instance, might lead to an immediate jump in the stock price, but the earnings effect suggests that this positive momentum could continue for days, weeks, or even months afterward. Conversely, a negative earnings surprise can trigger a downward drift. This delayed reaction is often attributed to various factors, including the slow diffusion of information, investor underreaction, or limited attention from market participants36, 37, 38. Analysts and investors may scrutinize the magnitude of the earnings surprise and the company's fundamentals to gauge the potential for a sustained earnings effect.

Hypothetical Example

Consider "TechInnovate Inc." (TII), a hypothetical technology company. Analysts had forecast TII to report earnings per share (EPS) of $1.50 for the recent quarter. However, TII announces an actual EPS of $1.75. This represents a positive earnings surprise. On the day of the announcement, TII's stock price jumps by 5%.

According to the earnings effect, investors might continue to process this positive news over the following weeks. This could lead to a continued, albeit slower, increase in TII's stock price as more investors become aware of the strong performance, update their valuation models, and adjust their positions. Conversely, if TII had reported an EPS of $1.20, a negative surprise, the stock might initially drop and then continue a downward trajectory as the market fully absorbs the disappointing results. This illustrates how the initial reaction can extend into a more prolonged "drift."

Practical Applications

The earnings effect has several practical applications in financial markets and portfolio management.

  • Trading Strategies: Some quantitative trading strategies attempt to capitalize on the post-earnings announcement drift by taking long positions in stocks with positive earnings surprises and short positions in stocks with negative surprises34, 35. However, the profitability of such strategies can be influenced by transaction costs and market liquidity32, 33.
  • Analyst Revisions: Companies' earnings announcements often prompt analysts to revise their future analyst forecasts and recommendations. These revisions can further contribute to the sustained price movement associated with the earnings effect.
  • Corporate Disclosure: Public companies are required by regulatory bodies like the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to make timely and comprehensive earnings disclosures. For instance, companies must file current reports on SEC Form 8-K to report material events, including earnings announcements, ensuring transparency and equal access to information for all stakeholders28, 29, 30, 31. The timing of these announcements can also be a factor, as delays or variability in announcement dates can be perceived negatively by the market27. Companies often provide "guidance" on future earnings, which significantly influences analyst forecasts and, consequently, the potential for an earnings surprise26.
  • Market Monitoring: Market participants, including institutional investors and individual traders, closely monitor earnings announcements as key catalysts for stock price movements. News organizations like Reuters frequently cover earnings releases and their immediate market impact, often highlighting positive or negative surprises22, 23, 24, 25.

Limitations and Criticisms

Despite its persistent observation, the earnings effect, particularly the post-earnings announcement drift, faces limitations and criticisms. One primary critique centers on the challenge it poses to the efficient market hypothesis (EMH). If markets were perfectly efficient, all new information, including earnings, should be instantly and fully reflected in prices, leaving no room for a prolonged drift19, 20, 21.

Explanations for the persistence of the earnings effect often involve behavioral biases, such as investor underreaction to new information due to limited attention or cognitive biases16, 17, 18. However, some argue that the drift might be attributable to methodological shortcomings in research studies or difficulties in accurately accounting for risk management15. For instance, a paper reviewing the post-earnings announcement drift acknowledged that an "all-encompassing explanation remains out of sight," highlighting the complexity and multifaceted nature of its underlying drivers, which include delayed information processing, risk premiums, investor sentiment, and various behavioral biases14. Furthermore, while the earnings effect has been observed globally, its magnitude and specific characteristics can vary across different markets and over time, potentially decreasing as information efficiency improves10, 11, 12, 13. The presence of high transaction costs or limits to arbitrage can also prevent sophisticated investors from fully exploiting the anomaly, thus allowing the drift to persist9.

Earnings Effect vs. Earnings Season

The earnings effect refers to the prolonged price movement of an individual stock after its earnings announcement, extending beyond the immediate reaction. It highlights how the market may gradually process new information over time. In contrast, earnings season is a specific period, typically a few weeks each quarter, during which a large number of publicly traded companies release their financial results. Earnings season is a broad chronological event, characterized by heightened trading activity and market volatility as investors react to a continuous stream of corporate news. The earnings effect is a specific market phenomenon that occurs during, and extends beyond, the general period of earnings season, focusing on the sustained price adjustment of individual securities in response to reported figures.

FAQs

What causes the earnings effect?

The earnings effect is believed to be caused by a combination of factors, including delayed information processing by investors, behavioral biases such as underreaction to unexpected news, and limits to arbitrage that prevent immediate price corrections6, 7, 8.

How long does the earnings effect typically last?

The duration of the earnings effect, particularly the post-earnings announcement drift, can vary. Research suggests it can persist for several weeks or even months following an earnings announcement3, 4, 5.

Can investors profit from the earnings effect?

While the earnings effect suggests predictable price movements, consistently profiting from it through trading strategies can be challenging. Factors such as transaction costs, market liquidity, and the diminishing magnitude of the drift over time can impact profitability1, 2.