Skip to main content
diversification.com
← Back to F Definitions

Futures basis

What Is Futures Basis?

Futures basis, often simply referred to as "basis," is the price difference between the current spot price of an asset and the price of its corresponding futures contracts for a specific delivery month. In the realm of derivatives trading, understanding futures basis is crucial for participants engaged in hedging, speculation, and arbitrage. This relationship reflects various factors, including carrying costs, supply and demand dynamics, and market expectations. The basis can be positive (contango) or negative (backwardation), providing insights into market sentiment and potential opportunities.

History and Origin

The concept underlying futures basis emerged alongside the formalization of futures contracts themselves. Early organized exchanges, such as the Chicago Board of Trade (CBOT), established in 1848, were created to provide a centralized venue for buyers and sellers to negotiate and formalize forward contracts for agricultural commodities. As these contracts became standardized and exchange-traded in 1864, the natural price relationship between the immediate (spot) market and future delivery became a fundamental aspect of trading. The continuous interplay between the cash price and the futures price, and thus the basis, has been a cornerstone of these markets since their inception, allowing participants to manage price risk and facilitate efficient commerce.

Key Takeaways

  • Futures basis is the difference between an asset's spot price and its futures price.
  • It serves as a key indicator of supply and demand dynamics in both the cash market and the futures market.
  • Basis tends to converge to zero as the futures contract approaches its expiration.
  • Participants use basis for hedging strategies, allowing them to manage price risk by locking in a price relationship rather than an absolute price.
  • Changes in futures basis can signal shifts in market conditions, such as unexpected supply disruptions or changes in demand.

Formula and Calculation

The formula for futures basis is straightforward:

Basis=Spot Price−Futures Price\text{Basis} = \text{Spot Price} - \text{Futures Price}

Where:

  • Spot Price: The current price of the underlying asset for immediate delivery.
  • Futures Price: The price of a specific futures contract for the same underlying asset, for a given delivery month.

For example, if the current spot price of crude oil is $80 per barrel and the futures contract for delivery next month is priced at $82 per barrel, the basis would be:
Basis=$80−$82=−$2\text{Basis} = \$80 - \$82 = -\$2
A negative basis indicates that the futures price is higher than the spot price, a market condition known as contango. Conversely, a positive basis (where the spot price is higher than the futures price) is known as backwardation.

Interpreting the Futures Basis

Interpreting the futures basis involves understanding its components and what its movements imply for the underlying asset. The basis provides critical information about the market's expectation of future spot price and the costs associated with holding the physical asset.

A strong or strengthening basis (spot price increasing relative to futures price, or futures price decreasing relative to spot price) suggests increasing demand or decreasing supply in the immediate cash market. This often happens when current supply is tight or there is strong immediate consumption. Conversely, a weak or weakening basis (spot price decreasing relative to futures price, or futures price increasing relative to spot price) suggests abundant current supply or weaker immediate demand. This can occur due to large harvests in agricultural commodity markets or an inventory build-up. The basis generally narrows as the contract approaches its expiration, ultimately converging to zero at the moment of expiration, reflecting the principle that the futures price must equal the spot price at delivery.

Hypothetical Example

Consider a farmer who expects to harvest corn in September. It is currently May, and the spot price of corn is $4.00 per bushel. The September corn futures contracts are trading at $4.15 per bushel.

In this scenario:

  • Spot Price = $4.00
  • September Futures Price = $4.15

The initial futures basis is calculated as:
Basis = $4.00 (Spot) - $4.15 (Futures) = -$0.15

This negative basis indicates that the market expects corn prices to be slightly higher in September, accounting for storage costs and the time value of money.

As September approaches, suppose the actual supply conditions suggest a larger-than-expected harvest. The spot price might fall to $3.90, and the September futures price might also adjust to $3.91. The new basis would be:
Basis = $3.90 (Spot) - $3.91 (Futures) = -$0.01

Notice how the futures basis has narrowed significantly as the contract neared its expiration, illustrating the convergence principle. This narrowing basis reflects the diminishing impact of carrying costs and the alignment of future expectations with current market realities.

Practical Applications

Futures basis is a fundamental concept in several practical applications across financial markets:

  • Hedging: Commercial entities, such as farmers, producers, or consumers of commodities, utilize basis hedging to mitigate price risk. By taking an opposite position in the futures market to their physical commodity exposure, they aim to lock in a price relationship (the basis) rather than an absolute price. For example, a grain elevator buying corn from farmers at a fluctuating spot price can sell futures contracts to protect against a drop in corn prices before they can sell the physical grain. The profitability then depends on the movement of the basis.
  • Arbitrage: For traders, understanding futures basis is essential for identifying potential arbitrage opportunities. If the basis deviates significantly from its theoretical fair value (which considers factors like interest rates and storage costs), traders may execute simultaneous trades in the spot and futures markets to profit from the temporary discrepancy. This activity helps ensure market efficiency.
  • Price Forecasting and Market Insight: Changes in basis provide valuable insights into current and expected supply-demand conditions. For instance, a strengthening basis in an agricultural commodity might signal unexpected weather issues or strong export demand, while a weakening basis could indicate an oversupply. Traders and analysts often monitor the basis of Fed Funds futures contracts for market expectations regarding the Federal Reserve's monetary policy decisions. The CME Group notes that Fed Funds futures serve as a key barometer for those following financial markets due to their predictive abilities regarding interest rates.5
  • Inventory Management: For businesses that hold significant inventories of raw materials, the futures basis can influence inventory decisions. A strong contango (futures price significantly above spot) might incentivize holding inventory due to the premium paid for future delivery, while backwardation (spot price significantly above futures) might encourage drawing down existing stocks. Regulation by bodies like the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), which enforces the Commodity Exchange Act, helps ensure transparency and integrity in these markets.4

Limitations and Criticisms

While futures basis is a powerful tool, its interpretation and application come with limitations and criticisms:

  • Market Imperfections: The theoretical convergence of basis to zero and its alignment with the cost of carry model assume perfectly efficient markets. However, real markets are subject to imperfections such as transaction costs, liquidity constraints, and information asymmetry, which can lead to persistent mispricing or basis anomalies. An Oxford Academic publication discusses how the cost of carry model "largely determines futures prices," but also presents "alternative explanations," acknowledging these complexities.3
  • Non-Storable Commodities: For non-storable commodities (e.g., electricity, services, or certain livestock), the concept of storage costs and convenience yield does not apply in the same way as for storable goods. This can lead to different basis behaviors that are less predictable by traditional models.
  • Exogenous Shocks: Unexpected events, such as natural disasters, geopolitical conflicts, or sudden policy changes, can drastically and unpredictably affect supply and demand, leading to sharp and volatile movements in the futures basis that are difficult to anticipate or hedge against.
  • Liquidity and Deliverability: The basis can also be affected by the liquidity of both the spot and futures markets, as well as the specific delivery terms of the futures contract. If the deliverable supply for a futures contract is limited or difficult to access, the basis might behave unexpectedly. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) actively oversees the use of derivatives by registered investment companies, including mutual funds and ETFs, to manage associated risks and ensure investor protection.2 Instances of firms allegedly failing to adequately disclose risks or misrepresenting the pricing of derivative products underscore the importance of robust regulatory oversight in preventing market misuse.1

Futures Basis vs. Cost of Carry

Futures basis is often confused with or directly related to the cost of carry, but they represent different aspects of futures pricing.

The futures basis is the observed market difference between the spot price and the futures price at any given moment. It is a real-time market value that can fluctuate due to supply/demand changes, market expectations, and other factors.

The cost of carry is the theoretical cost of holding an underlying asset from the present until the expiration date of the futures contracts. For financial assets, this typically includes interest rates incurred on borrowed funds to buy the asset, minus any income generated by the asset (like dividends or coupons). For commodities, it includes storage costs, insurance, and financing costs, minus any convenience yield (the benefit of holding the physical commodity).

In a perfectly efficient market, the futures price should theoretically equal the spot price plus the cost of carry. Therefore, the futures basis should reflect the negative of the cost of carry (Basis = Spot Price - Futures Price $\approx$ Spot Price - (Spot Price + Cost of Carry) = -Cost of Carry). Any significant deviation from this theoretical relationship would create an arbitrage opportunity, which market participants would quickly exploit, thereby pushing the basis back towards its fair value.

FAQs

What does a positive futures basis mean?

A positive futures basis, also known as backwardation, means that the spot price of an asset is higher than its futures price for a future delivery month. This often indicates immediate scarcity or strong current demand for the physical asset, making it more valuable in the present than for future delivery.

What does a negative futures basis mean?

A negative futures basis, known as contango, indicates that the futures price is higher than the current spot price. This is a more common market condition, especially for storable commodities, as the futures price typically includes the cost of carry (like storage costs and interest rates) associated with holding the asset until the future delivery date.

How does futures basis change over time?

The futures basis tends to narrow as the futures contract approaches its expiration date. At the moment of expiration, the futures price and the spot price for the underlying asset converge, meaning the basis should theoretically reach zero. This convergence is a fundamental characteristic of futures contracts.

Why is futures basis important for hedging?

Futures basis is crucial for hedging because it allows market participants to manage price risk by focusing on the relationship between the spot and futures prices, rather than trying to predict absolute price levels. A hedger's profitability depends on basis risk—the risk that the basis will change unexpectedly between the time the hedge is placed and when it is lifted. By locking in a basis, businesses can reduce their exposure to adverse price movements in the underlying commodity or financial instrument.