Longevity swaps

What Is Longevity Swaps?

A longevity swap is a type of derivative contract designed to transfer the financial risk associated with people living longer than anticipated, known as longevity risk. This financial instrument falls under the broader category of risk management within pension and insurance finance. Primarily used by pension funds and insurance companies, longevity swaps help these entities hedge against the uncertainty of future payouts caused by increasing life expectancy among their members or policyholders.

In a typical longevity swap, one party (the protection buyer, usually a pension fund or an insurer) makes a series of fixed payments to a counterparty (the protection seller, often a reinsurer or investment bank). In return, the protection buyer receives variable payments from the counterparty that are linked to the actual mortality experience of a specified group of individuals. This mechanism allows the pension fund or insurer to insulate itself from the financial strain if its beneficiaries live longer than initially forecast, as the variable payments from the swap would increase to offset the higher pension or annuity payouts.

History and Origin

The concept of managing longevity risk gained prominence as global life expectancies steadily increased throughout the 20th and early 21st centuries, posing significant challenges for long-term financial obligations. While early discussions around transferring longevity risk began in the early 2000s with proposed instruments like longevity bonds, the market for longevity swaps truly emerged in the late 2000s. These instruments provided a more flexible and customizable solution for hedging against increased lifespans.⁸

A notable early transaction that allowed capital markets investors to directly assume longevity risk was a £500 million, 40-year longevity swap between UK insurer Canada Life and J.P. Morgan in July 2008. ⁷This pioneering deal involved Canada Life making fixed payments while J.P. Morgan made variable payments tied to the actual mortality experience of a large cohort of policyholders. The UK market has historically been a leader in the development and adoption of longevity swaps, driven by the significant liabilities of its large defined benefit plans.
⁶

Key Takeaways

• Longevity swaps are financial instruments used by pension funds and insurers to manage the risk of beneficiaries living longer than expected.
• They typically involve the transfer of variable payments linked to actual mortality experience in exchange for fixed payments.
• The primary goal is to hedge against longevity risk, which is the financial exposure arising from increased life expectancy.
• Longevity swaps help stabilize future cash flows for entities with long-term payment obligations, such as retirement benefit providers.
• Unlike full buy-outs, longevity swaps allow the pension fund to retain control over its underlying assets.

Interpreting Longevity Swaps

Longevity swaps are interpreted based on their effectiveness in mitigating future payout uncertainty. For a pension plan or insurer, a longevity swap is successful if the variable payments received from the counterparty closely match the increased benefit payments due to members living longer. The structure of the swap essentially locks in the cost of future pension or annuity payments, removing the exposure to adverse changes in population mortality trends.

The success of a longevity swap relies heavily on the accuracy of the underlying demographic data and the actuarial assumptions used to price the fixed leg of the swap. Parties entering into these agreements engage in extensive data analysis, often leveraging specialized actuarial science expertise, to model future mortality improvements. The terms of the swap will specify how "actual" mortality rates are determined, which can be based on the specific experience of the covered population (indemnity-based) or a broader population index (index-based).
⁵

Hypothetical Example

Consider "Alpha Pension Fund," a hypothetical defined benefit scheme with £1 billion in liabilities linked to its retired members. The fund's actuaries have projected that its members will live, on average, until age 85. However, there's a risk that medical advancements or lifestyle improvements could extend this life expectancy, forcing the fund to pay out pensions for a longer period than anticipated.

To mitigate this, Alpha Pension Fund enters into a longevity swap with a reinsurance company. Under the terms of the swap:

1. Fixed Leg Payment: Alpha Pension Fund agrees to pay the reinsurance company a fixed annual premium based on the current best estimate of its members' life expectancy and future pension payouts.
2. Floating Leg Payment: The reinsurance company agrees to pay Alpha Pension Fund an amount each year that corresponds to the actual pension payments made to the covered members.

If Alpha Pension Fund's members, on average, live longer than the initial projection, the actual pension payments will exceed the fund's original expectations. In this scenario, the reinsurance company's floating leg payments to Alpha Pension Fund would increase, covering the additional payout burden. Conversely, if members die sooner than expected, the floating payments would decrease, and Alpha Pension Fund would still make its fixed payment, resulting in a net cost for the protection. This arrangement effectively transfers the risk of unexpectedly high longevity to the reinsurance company.

Practical Applications

Longevity swaps are predominantly used by institutional investors with long-term, fixed-income-like liabilities that are sensitive to changes in human longevity. Their primary applications include:

• Pension Scheme De-risking: Many pension funds, particularly large defined benefit plans, utilize longevity swaps to reduce their exposure to the uncertainty of how long their members will live. This helps them achieve greater financial certainty and stability in their long-term funding.
• Insurance Company Capital Management: Life insurance companies that issue annuities are also exposed to longevity risk, as longer policyholder lifespans mean more annuity payments. Longevity swaps allow these insurers to offload this risk, optimizing their capital requirements and improving solvency ratios.
• Facilitating Pension Buy-ins/Buy-outs: While not the same as a direct buy-in, longevity swaps can be a precursor or complementary tool. Insurers who take on pension scheme liabilities through buy-ins often use longevity swaps with reinsurance firms to manage the longevity risk component of those large transactions.
• Market Growth and Notable Deals: The market for longevity swaps has seen significant activity, particularly in the UK. For instance, in March 2025, the BT Pension Scheme, one of the UK's largest private sector pension schemes, completed two longevity reinsurance transactions totaling £10 billion with Swiss Re and Reinsurance Group of America (RGA), further protecting itself from unexpected increases in member life expectancy.

#⁴# Limitations and Criticisms

Despite their utility in risk management, longevity swaps have several limitations and criticisms. One significant factor is their complexity and cost. Setting up a longevity swap involves substantial upfront costs and ongoing expenses, including the reinsurer's fee, which can range from 3% to 4% of the projected pension cashflows for pensioner-only transactions. Th³is complexity and expense can make them less attractive for smaller pension schemes.

Another critique is that while longevity swaps address mortality risk (specifically, the risk of people living longer), they do not hedge other significant risks faced by pension funds, such as investment risk or inflation risk. Th²is contrasts with full pension buy-in or buy-out solutions, which typically transfer all these risks to an insurer. As a result, schemes might still need to manage their assets carefully to meet their remaining fixed payment obligations under the swap.

Furthermore, issues such as basis risk can arise if the actual mortality experience of the covered population deviates significantly from the index used in an index-based swap. While an indemnity-based swap minimizes this by tying payments to the specific population's experience, it can be more resource-intensive to price and manage. The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) has noted the need for governments to stimulate a fully functioning longevity risk market, including standardized longevity swap derivatives, to enhance their effectiveness and liquidity.

#¹# Longevity Swaps vs. Pension Buy-ins

While both longevity swaps and pension buy-in agreements are strategies for pension funds to manage risk, they differ significantly in their scope and mechanism. A longevity swap focuses exclusively on transferring longevity risk. The pension fund retains its underlying assets and continues to make pension payments to its members. It simply exchanges fixed payments for variable payments from a reinsurance counterparty that will offset the financial impact if members live longer than expected. The pension fund still bears the investment risk, inflation risk, and other financial risks associated with its assets and liabilities. In contrast, a pension buy-in (or buy-out) involves the pension fund paying a lump sum premium to an insurance company in exchange for a bulk annuity policy. This policy covers a specific block of members' benefits, and the insurer takes on full responsibility for making those future pension payments, thereby transferring longevity, investment, and other financial risks entirely from the pension fund to the insurer. The main point of confusion lies in their shared goal of de-risking pension obligations, but the methods and the extent of risk transfer are distinct.

FAQs

What is the primary purpose of a longevity swap?

The primary purpose of a longevity swap is to protect pension funds and insurance companies from the financial impact of their members or policyholders living longer than anticipated. It helps hedge against the risk that longer lifespans will lead to higher-than-expected payouts.

Who are the typical parties involved in a longevity swap?

The typical parties in a longevity swap are a protection buyer, usually a pension fund or an insurer, and a protection seller, often a reinsurance company or an investment bank.

Does a longevity swap remove all risks for a pension fund?

No, a longevity swap primarily removes longevity risk. While it hedges against the financial impact of members living longer, the pension fund still retains other significant risks, such as investment risk (the risk that its assets will not generate sufficient returns) and inflation risk.